Republic
Plato's dialogue in which Socrates describes an ideal city-state, including its hierarchical social structure and the noble lie used to sustain it.
As defined in 135 | Shadi Bartsch on Plato, Vergil, Confucius, and Modernity
Other definitions
A system of government in which elites make decisions about governance and leadership but citizens retain the power to change those elites through periodic elections, distinguished from direct or pure democracy where citizens vote on candidates and policies directly.
Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan interview | US politics | The New Statesman
Where it comes up · 4
- Great Minds - Montesquieu and the Beginnings of Political Science10 claims
- 135 | Shadi Bartsch on Plato, Vergil, Confucius, and Modernity2 claims
- Everything We Think We Know About Early Human History is Wrong | David Wengrow on Downstream1 claim
- Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan interview | US politics | The New Statesman1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 14Search all claims for “Republic” →
- Plato's noble lie—the founding myth in the Republic that citizens were born from the earth as gold, silver, or bronze humans to keep them loyal to their social classes—has disturbed Western thinkers as a blueprint for eugenics and totalitarianism, whereas Chinese articles under Xi Jinping treat it as obvious common sense: of course society is hierarchical and of course rulers must lie to keep people happy, possibly even as a way to expose the Chinese government's own noble lie.135 | Shadi Bartsch on Plato, Vergil, Confucius, and Modernity
- Hernán Cortés and the Spanish conquistadors were able to conquer the Aztec empire partly by making alliances with the city-state of Tlaxcala, which had a democratic republican structure similar to Athens versus Sparta, with records of parliamentary debates surviving in Spanish colonial documents.Everything We Think We Know About Early Human History is Wrong | David Wengrow on Downstream
- The founding fathers were afraid of pure democracy; Madison specifically was against pure democracy and wanted a republic instead, where elites decide who leads but the people can change the elites every four years.Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan interview | US politics | The New Statesman
- Jefferson's idealization of the yeoman farmer as the ideal citizen of a democratic republic is anticipated by and derives from Montesquieu's conception of virtue and the need for economic independence and rough equality to maintain republican government.Great Minds - Montesquieu and the Beginnings of Political Science
- In the ideology of the American Revolution and Constitution, there is constant, almost obsessive reference to political virtue, understood as the necessity to maintain virtue if we wish to maintain our felicity and have a republic.Great Minds - Montesquieu and the Beginnings of Political Science
- Aristocracy is a form of republic where a hereditary landed aristocratic elite represents a privileged segment of society, and the characteristic spirit necessary for aristocratic government is moderation, meaning a Newtonian balance of the elements of society.Great Minds - Montesquieu and the Beginnings of Political Science
- Montesquieu said that republics must be small and would be nice if they were islands, so when faced with the vast non-island territory of America's eastern seaboard, the Federalist papers had to argue that Montesquieu was wrong about the geographic necessity for republic smallness.Great Minds - Montesquieu and the Beginnings of Political Science
- The founding fathers were forced to take a leap of faith in applying Montesquieu's principles to a new, geographically vast republic with the hope that virtue would be maintained and the balance of powers would guarantee individual liberty, and fortunately for the United States it worked out.Great Minds - Montesquieu and the Beginnings of Political Science
- Republic is the third kind of government that Montesquieu identifies, which he breaks down into two forms: aristocracies and democracies, where democracy means a government allowing some degree of representation and input from common people (such as the English system with property requirements), not universal suffrage as the modern meaning.Great Minds - Montesquieu and the Beginnings of Political Science
- Plato's Republic attempts to create an ideal state with perfect people and perfect government, which allows us to criticize actual societies but is utopian in the pejorative sense and has limited utility for analyzing governments that actually exist in the world, since no such society ever exists.Great Minds - Montesquieu and the Beginnings of Political Science