YouTube17m· Jan 2025· cataloged

Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan interview | US politics | The New Statesman


What this covers

This is an 18-minute interview in which the New Statesman's Kate Lamble questions the geopolitical analyst Robert D Kaplan, whose book Waste Land: A World in Permanent Crisis was due out that month. Kaplan treats American decline as already well underway, and he presents Donald Trump's return as an accelerant, not the cause. He calls the second-term Trump more experienced and more vindictive than the first-term one. The evidence he offers is economic as well as political. In 1945 the United States held half the world's manufacturing capacity and now holds 16%. Its debt is about $36 trillion and rising by roughly $1 trillion a year, and he compares congressional budget debates to the last days of Rome.

The middle of the conversation is about institutions. Kaplan defines the "deep state" as the bureaucracy a great power needs to run an empire, not a hidden cabal. He argues that Trump's appointees, many of whom dislike the agencies they now lead, will erode the part of American power that those agencies manage. He also claims that presidential instinct has fallen since the Cold War, from Truman to George H.W. Bush down to a run of mediocre presidents and one catastrophic one. He is even more contentious about party selection. He defends the old "smoke-filled rooms" and criticises pure democracy through state primaries, which he says reward extreme candidates. He cites Madison's fear of direct rule, and he suggests Jeb Bush, not Trump, would have been the 2016 nominee under the old system.

The last stretch looks outward. Kaplan says American action is about preventing worse outcomes, not doing good. He credits the US Navy with keeping India and China from war, and he traces the Middle East's instability to the Ottoman collapse, not October 7. He argues that when all the great powers are declining, the result is chaos, not fairness. He also holds that decline can be reversed, pointing to earlier leadership upheavals in American history, such as the era of Andrew Jackson, that looked catastrophic at the time.

Sharpest takeaway

The United States is in relative decline across military, economic, and political dimensions due to weakened presidential quality, deteriorating bureaucratic capacity, and unsustainable debt, though decline is not inevitable and could be reversed through radical leadership changes, with global implications of reduced American stabilizing power leading to increased international chaos.

  • American manufacturing capacity fell from 50% of world total in 1945 to 16% today, while national debt reaches $36 trillion growing at ~$1 trillion annually with no political will to address it
  • Presidential quality has declined since the Cold War, and the foreign policy bureaucracy that manages 80% of imperial operations is deteriorating due to Trump's appointment of inexperienced and ideologically hostile figures
  • Without American naval and diplomatic presence to stabilize regions like the Middle East and Asia-Pacific, international conflict and state collapse become more likely, as seen in the chaotic Middle East after Ottoman collapse

The claims · ranked84 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.75

The founding fathers were afraid of pure democracy; Madison specifically was against pure democracy and wanted a republic instead, where elites decide who leads but the people can change the elites every four years.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“the founding fathers were actually afraid of pure democracy Madison was against it he wanted a republic not a democracy all right what's the difference the difference is in a republic the elites decide but the people get to change the elites every four years”

0.75

The American federal bureaucracy that manages foreign policy consists of secretaries of state and defense, deputy secretaries, under secretaries, assistant secretaries, and deputy assistant secretaries, and has been running the American Empire since 1945.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“there's the other thing that nobody writes about or talks about but which is 80% of foreign policy and that's the bureaucracy not just the secretaries of state and defense but the uh the deputy secretaries the under secretaries the assistant secretaries of which there are many the deputy assistant secretaries America has been an Empire since 1945 and it's this layered bureaucracy that runs the Empire”

0.69

In 1945 when World War II ended, half of the world's manufacturing capacity was in the United States, and this advantage lasted for decades, allowing figures like Kissinger and Nixon to exercise significant power, but now America accounts for only 16% of the world's manufacturing capacity.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“in 1945 when World War II ended half of the world's manufacturing capacity was in the United States um and that lasted for decades it it declined very gradually one of the reasons why why you know Kissinger and Nixon could do so much is because America was much more powerful then you know now Amer America accounts for only 16% of the world's manufacturing capacity”

0.69

The United States cannot order events in the world the way it used to—the Middle East was relatively quiet for decades under American tutelage, but this is no longer the case, and America used to dominate the Asia Pacific but now China does.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“the United States cannot order events in the world the way it used to the Middle East was very was relatively quiet for decades under American tutelage when there was an Arab Israeli War was the Americans who quickly ended it essentially that's no longer the case the Americans used to dominate the Asia Pacific now China does”

0.69

Under pure democracy with state primaries, the most extreme person wins because primaries draw out the most extreme voters, so instead of elites deciding the two candidates, voters choose between extreme candidates.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“now we have a pure democracy with primaries for each state which means that the most extreme person wins uh uh essentially because primaries draw out the most extreme voters and so instead of Elites deciding the two candidates um we have pure democracy deciding it”

0.69

In American history, there have been dramatic changes in leadership at specific moments (founding era → Andrew Jackson, etc.) that were seen as catastrophic at the time but led to more democratic society and rebirths of American statehood.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“if you look at American history we had the founders who were basic and their sons who were the first six presidents then there was a dramatic change with the seventh president when Andrew Jackson replaced John Quincy Adams and you CA you got in all these corrupt ruun characters from the frontier which was then Tennessee Kentucky and places like that and the founders were absolutely shocked just like the elite today is shocked at Trump you know when they lost these Virginians and uh bostonians lost control to these ruffe corrupt people from the Appalachians essentially and it was corrupt and it was free willing but over time it led to a more Democratic Society”

0.69

The United States cannot order events in the world the way it used to; the Middle East was relatively quiet for decades under American tutelage and when Arab-Israeli Wars occurred Americans quickly ended them, but this is no longer the case.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“the United States cannot order events in the world the way it used to the Middle East was very was relatively quiet for decades under American tutelage when there was an Arab Israeli War was the Americans who quickly ended it essentially that's no longer the case”

0.69

Americans used to dominate the Asia Pacific, but now China does.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“the Americans used to dominate the Asia Pacific now China does”

0.69

Trump had no experience with the presidency and no knowledge of government when he came in the first time, and thought he could press a button and things would happen, not understanding how weak the presidency is as an institution.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“he's he's got some experience he knows that he because when he came in the first time not only had he no experience with the presidency but he didn't even know anybody who is in government essentially you know he had no knowledge he thought he could press a button and things would happen and that's not how it works uh what's amazing is how weak the presidency is as a general institution”

0.68

The quality of presidential instinct has declined significantly since the Cold War, with a succession of mediocre presidents (Clinton, Obama) and one catastrophic president (George W. Bush), contrasting with excellent Cold War presidents from Harry Truman to George H.W. Bush.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“during the Cold War we had a number of excellent presidents from Harry Truman to George HW Bush Jimmy Carter who just died it was actually the weakest of those presidents in terms of presidential Instinct on foreign policy despite all the great things that have been written about him in the past two weeks he was the weakest um since the end of the Cold War um the pre the quality of the presidency has declined in terms of presidential Instinct we've had Clinton George W bush who may have been the worst president of the last few decades um Obama who was a mediocrity Clinton was a mediocrity and then there's Trump”

0.68

Ironically, the people who are the most honest, least wealthy, and most hardworking are the 'deep state' that everybody attacks—people earning regular salaries from non-wealthy backgrounds with extremely good judgment on parts of the world they are experts on.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“ironically the people who are the most honest and the least wealthy and the most hardworking are the very deep state that everybody attacks you know um the Deep state is actually very good it's made of clean cut people earning regular salaries not from wealthy parents and uh and often have extremely good judgment on the parts of the world that they're experts on”

0.68

Congressional budget debates resemble the last days of ancient Rome, with no one in the room remotely responsible—they just want to spend and spend on different things—and this debt accumulation takes up more of the budget, leaving less for defense and social issues, creating a compounding problem as in empires throughout history.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“when you watch Congress debate the budget it's like the last days of ancient Rome I mean there is nobody in the room who's even remotely responsible they just want to spend and spend and spend um each party on different things and this debt accumulates and takes up more of the budget and there's less money to spend on defense on social issues it's like a building problem and as I lay out in the peace this is how Empires decline over history you know it's not you you know it's not just ancient Rome it's you know most Empires throughout history have decline because of economic reasons”

0.68

In his first term, Trump had no experience with the presidency and did not know anyone in government; he thought he could press a button and things would happen, which shows how weak the presidency is as an institution designed for weak managers rather than world-historical figures like Roosevelt and Lincoln.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“he's got some experience he knows that he because when he came in the first time not only had he no experience with the presidency but he didn't even know anybody who is in government essentially you know he had no knowledge he thought he could press a button and things would happen and that's not how it works uh what's amazing is how weak the presidency is as a general institution I mean it's made for weak managers not for uh World historical figures like Roosevelt and Lincoln who are the exceptions to the rule”

0.68

American geopolitical action is not a matter of doing good but a matter of preventing worse things from happening.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“it's not a matter of doing good it's a matter of preventing worse things from happening”

0.68

The real problem in the Middle East predates October 7, 2023 and stems from the collapse of the Ottoman Empire, for which no solution has been found, and without imperial overriding force from great powers, the region has experienced tremendous warfare.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“the real problem in the Middle East is that it was the collapse of the Ottoman Empire and there's been no solution found to that collapse and and without any Imperial overriding Force the Americans are weaker less respected in the Middle East the Russians are weaker you know than they used to be in the Middle East China is interested in terms of trade and economics but so far not in great power military um political means the Middle East has been on its own without great powers to oversee the situation so to speak and that has led to Warfare tremendous Warfare”

0.68

The deep state is properly defined as a great bureaucracy that a great power needs to operate, not as unnamed people running things behind the scenes.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“the Deep state has been used to define people who nobody knows who they are who are really running things behind the scenes and that's true because uh you know a great power needs a great bureaucracy”

0.68

In 1945 when World War II ended, half of the world's manufacturing capacity was in the United States, and this advantage lasted for decades, gradually declining.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“well in 1945 when World War II ended half of the world's manufacturing capacity was in the United States um and that lasted for decades it it declined very gradually”

0.68

American great power stabilization is not about 'doing good' but about 'preventing worse things from happening.'

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“it's not a matter of doing good it's a matter of preventing worse things from happening”

0.64

A world where all the great powers are declining will lead not to a fairer or better world, but to more chaos.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“so we're really facing a world where all the great powers are declining and that as I point out at the end of the piece will lead not to a fairer world a better world but to more chaos”

0.64

The United States has accumulated approximately $36 trillion in debt, growing at about $1 trillion per year, and neither the Republicans nor the Democrats have the maturity and fiscal discipline to address the debt problem.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“there's the debt uh which is about $ 36 trillion and growing dramatically at about a trillion dollars a year and this and neither party neither the Republicans nor the Dem Democrats have anywhere near the maturity and fiscal discipline to deal with the debt”

0.63

The bureaucracy that runs the American Empire has declined dramatically under Trump (2017-2021) and is set to decline again because Trump appoints people of lower quality than all previous presidents except perhaps his first term.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“America has been an Empire since 1945 and it's this layered bureaucracy that runs the Empire and under Trump as I argue in the piece this bureaucracy had went downhill dramatically between 2017 and 2021 and is and is set to go down dramatically again because the quality of people that Trump appoints whatever you may think of the quality under Biden another mediocrity and others was much higher under under all the previous presidents with the exception of trump”

0.63

In his second term, Trump is more experienced and more vindictive, and has appointed people many of whom have no bureaucratic experience and many of whom hate the very bureaucracies they have been empowered to run, which will lead to a decline in American power in the 80% that is run by the bureaucracy.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“Trump and this time around Trump is more experienced he's more vindictive um and he you know he's got people around him many of whom have no experience in the bureaucracy many of whom hate the very bureaucracies they've been empowered to run um and so uh we're going to see a decline in American power in the 80% that's run by the bureaucracy”

0.63

For decades, party leaders in 'smoke-filled rooms' behind the scenes decided who would be the presidential candidates; though this was undemocratic and sleazy, it actually worked very well, as evidenced by the fact that if this system had still been in place in 2016, Trump would never have been the Republican nominee and Jeb Bush would have been, which would have resulted in a very good president like his father.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“for decades the party leaders in so-called Smoke Filled rooms behind the scenes decided who would be the candidates for president and though that was undemocratic and sleazy it actually worked very well had the party leaders made those still been in power in 2017 in 2016 Trump never would have been the Republican nominee Jeb Bush would have been the Republican nominee and he would have go gone on to be a a very good president like his father not like his brother”

0.62

A world without one dominant great power would likely be more equal but also more ineffectual, similar to how the UN is equal but totally ineffectual because it includes members of very unequal power (France on the Security Council but not India, which is more powerful and consequential).

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“it could be more equal but also more ineffectual I mean the UN is equal and it's totally ineffectual I mean that's the world you know um you the problem with the UN is not the UN per se it's that it's you know it's the fact that um France is a member of the security Council and India which is much more powerful and consequential than France is not”

0.62

Despite economic and political decline, the U.S. will still have very significant but not as significant as it used to be a place on the world stage, because a world of great powers is more stable than a world without great powers or with very weak great powers.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“the US's place on the world's stage will still be very very significant but but not as significant as it used to be you can say what you want about great Powers you can hate them all this but a world of great Powers is a more stable world than a world where there's no no great powers or very weaken great Powers”

0.62

Without the United States Navy in the Indian Ocean and the Western Pacific over the past few decades, there probably would have been more wars between India and China because the American Navy essentially stabilized the situation.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“you'd have more for instance W without the United States Navy over the last few decades you probably would have had more Wars between India and China because with the American Navy in the Indian Ocean and the Western Pacific it essentially stabilized the situation in many ways”

0.62

During the Cold War, the U.S. had a number of excellent presidents from Harry Truman to George H.W. Bush, but their quality of presidential instinct on foreign policy has declined since the Cold War ended.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“now during the Cold War we had a number of excellent presidents from Harry Truman to George HW Bush Jimmy Carter who just died it was actually the weakest of those presidents in terms of presidential Instinct on foreign policy despite all the great things that have been written about him in the past two weeks he was the weakest um since the end of the Cold War um the pre the quality of the presidency has declined in terms of presidential Instinct”

0.62

Congressional debate over the budget resembles 'the last days of ancient Rome' with no one in the room remotely responsible; both parties just want to spend on different things, accumulating debt that takes up more of the budget and leaves less for defense and social issues.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“it's it's amazing I mean when you watch Congress debate the budget it's like the last days of ancient Rome I mean there is nobody in the room who's even remotely responsible they just want to spend and spend and spend um each party on different things and this debt accumulates and takes up more of the budget and there's less money to spend on defense on social issues it's like a building problem”

0.62

The founding fathers, including Madison, were actually afraid of pure democracy and wanted a republic instead, where elites decide but the people get to change the elites every four years.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“the founding fathers were actually afraid of pure democracy Madison was against it he wanted a republic not a democracy all right what's the difference the difference is in a republic the elites decide but the people get to change the elites every four years”

0.62

Neither the Republican nor Democratic party has anywhere near the maturity and fiscal discipline to deal with the national debt.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“and this and neither party neither the Republicans nor the Dem Democrats have anywhere near the maturity and fiscal discipline to deal with the debt”

0.62

For decades, party leaders in 'smoke-filled rooms' behind the scenes decided who would be the candidates for president; while undemocratic and sleazy, this system actually worked very well.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“for decades the party leaders in so-called Smoke Filled rooms behind the scenes decided who would be the candidates for president and though that was undemocratic and sleazy it actually worked very well”

0.62

Primary elections draw out the most extreme voters, so the most extreme person wins, meaning pure democracy produces more extreme candidates than elite-managed systems.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“now we have a pure democracy with primaries for each state which means that the most extreme person wins uh uh essentially because primaries draw out the most extreme voters and so instead of Elites deciding the two candidates um we have pure democracy deciding it and the result has been worse”

0.62

Without the United States Navy in the Indian Ocean and Western Pacific over the past decades, India and China probably would have had more wars between them.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“you'd have more for instance W without the United States Navy over the last few decades you probably would have had more Wars between India and China because with the American Navy in the Indian Ocean and the Western Pacific it essentially stabilized the situation in many ways”

0.62

The Deep State is made of clean-cut people earning regular salaries not from wealthy parents and often have extremely good judgment on the parts of the world they're experts on.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“the Deep state is actually very good it's made of clean cut people earning regular salaries not from wealthy parents and uh and often have extremely good judgment on the parts of the world that they're experts on”

0.62

The term 'Deep State' has been used to describe people who nobody knows who are really running things behind the scenes, but this is actually true because a great power needs a great bureaucracy.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“the Deep state has been used to define people who nobody knows who they are who are really running things behind the scenes and that's true because uh you know a great power needs a great bureaucracy”

0.62

The real problem in the Middle East is the collapse of the Ottoman Empire with no solution found to that collapse, and without any imperial overriding force, the region has been on its own without great powers to oversee the situation.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“the real problem in the Middle East is that it was the collapse of the Ottoman Empire and there's been no solution found to that collapse and and without any Imperial overriding Force the Americans are weaker less respected in the Middle East the Russians are weaker you know than they used to be in the Middle East China is interested in terms of trade and economics but so far not in great power military um political means the Middle East has been on its own without great powers to oversee the situation”

0.62

The people who are the most honest, least wealthy, hardworking, and have extremely good judgment on their areas of expertise are the ones in the 'Deep State' that everybody attacks.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“ironically the people who are the most honest and the least wealthy and the most hardworking are the very deep state that everybody attacks”

0.61

Most empires throughout history have declined because of economic reasons and reasons indirectly related to economic causes.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“as I lay out in the peace this is how Empires decline over history you know it's not just ancient Rome it's you know most Empires throughout history have decline because of economic reasons and because of reasons related indirectly to economic reasons”

0.59

A world without a dominant great power would look like a world of more chaos and anarchy, with more wars.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“what does a world without one dominant great power look like a world of more chaos and Anarchy a world of more Wars”

0.59

A world without one dominant great power is not more equal but more ineffectual, as demonstrated by the UN, which is equal but totally ineffectual.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“it could be more equal but also more ineffectual I mean the UN is equal and it's totally ineffectual”

0.57

Washington is in a very decadent state controlled by money, and in Trump's second administration, proximity to power will determine how much money multi-billionaires make since they won't have to go through the normal bureaucratic process.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“Washington is in a very decadent state it's controlled by money and in Trump's second Administration proximity to the president will determine how much money B multi-billionaires make they won't have to go through the bureaucracy which is how stable states do it you you know you have to apply for permits you know there's a Security and Exchange Commission”

0.57

One threat of a second Trump term is that money has taken over the presidency, exemplified by Elon Musk, who despite being worth $50 billion, also insists on determining policy.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“one of the threats of a second Trump term is that money has taken over the presidency and all about it look at Elon Musk I I mean you know it's not enough that he's worth $50 billion or so but he has to determine policy as well um so that's what I worry about”

0.57

America is poorer than it used to be and America is more decadent than it used to be.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“America is poorer than it used to be and America is more decadent than it used to be”

0.57

America's place in the world is weaker than it used to be, America is poorer than it used to be, and America is more decadent than it used to be.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“America's place in the world is weaker uh than it used to be America is poorer than it used to be and America is more decadent than it used to be”

0.57

Post-Cold War presidents—including Clinton (a mediocrity), George W. Bush (possibly the worst president of the last few decades), and Obama (a mediocrity)—have had declining quality of presidential instinct compared to Cold War-era presidents.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“we've had Clinton George W bush who may have been the worst president of the last few decades um Obama who was a mediocrity Clinton was a mediocrity”

0.57

Under Trump's first administration (2017-2021), the foreign policy bureaucracy declined dramatically, and it is set to decline dramatically again because the quality of people Trump appoints is lower than those appointed by previous presidents (except Trump himself).

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“under Trump as I argue in the piece this bureaucracy had went downhill dramatically between 2017 and 2021 and is and is set to go down dramatically again because the quality of people that Trump appoints whatever you may think of the quality under Biden another mediocrity and others was much higher under under all the previous presidents with the exception of trump”

0.57

In his second term, Trump is more experienced, more vindictive, and has appointed people around him many of whom have no experience in the bureaucracy and many of whom hate the very bureaucracies they have been empowered to run.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“Trump and this time around Trump is more experienced he's more vindictive um and he you know he's got people around him many of whom have no experience in the bureaucracy many of whom hate the very bureaucracies they've been empowered to run”

0.57

Washington is in a decadent state controlled by money, and in Trump's second administration proximity to power and proximity to the president will determine how much money multi-billionaires make, without having to go through the bureaucracy as in stable states.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“Washington is in a very decadent state it's controlled by money and in Trump's second Administration proximity to power proximity to the president will determine how much money B multi-billionaires make they won't have to go through the bureaucracy which is how stable states do it you you know you have to apply for permits you know there's a Security and Exchange Commission”

0.55

The result of shifting to pure democracy through primaries has been worse [in terms of presidential quality and governance outcomes].

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“and the result has been worse”

0.55

There is already significant chaos in multiple regions (beyond what gets reported), essentially existing as a normal way of doing things, with Haiti as an extreme example that gets occasional media attention.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“we'll see more of that I think we there's already a lot of it but it's not written about because it's beyond the radar screen you know essentially you know it's almost a normal way of doing things like Haiti is an extreme example so we read about it but only occasionally”

0.55

American history shows that when Andrew Jackson replaced John Quincy Adams as the seventh president, it brought in corrupt and rough characters from the frontier (Tennessee, Kentucky, Appalachia), which the elite were shocked by, just as the modern elite are shocked by Trump.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“there was a dramatic change with the seventh president when Andrew Jackson replaced John Quincy Adams and you CA you got in all these corrupt ruun characters from the frontier which was then Tennessee Kentucky and places like that and the founders were absolutely shocked just like the elite today is shocked at Trump you know when they lost these Virginians and uh bostonians lost control to these ruffe corrupt people from the Appalachians essentially”

0.55

The presidency as an institution is made for weak managers, not for world historical figures like Roosevelt and Lincoln, which are the exceptions to the rule.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“what's amazing is how weak the presidency is as a general institution I mean it's made for weak managers not for uh World historical figures like Roosevelt and Lincoln who are the exceptions to the rule”

0.55

America currently accounts for only 16% of the world's manufacturing capacity, down from 50% in 1945.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“now Amer America accounts for only 16% of the world's manufacturing capacity”

0.55

Though the Jackson era was corrupt and free-wheeling, over time it led to a more Democratic Society.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“and it was corrupt and it was free willing but over time it led to a more Democratic Society”

0.54

The United States has accumulated national debt of approximately $36 trillion, which is growing dramatically at about a trillion dollars a year.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“there's the debt uh which is about $ 36 trillion and growing dramatically at about a trillion dollars a year”

0.53

We are going to see a decline in American power in the 80% of foreign policy run by the bureaucracy as a result of Trump's second term, while the presidential instinct decisions could go in either way because Trump is very unpredictable and has no well-thought-out world view.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“we're going to see a decline in American power in the 80% that's run by the bureaucracy as far as the presidential Instinct decisions that could go in either way Trump is very unpredictable because he has no well-thought out world viw”

0.53

A new regime in Iran is probable, possibly even in 2025, certainly in the next few years.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“we're probably going to see probably I've been saying this for 20 years now everybody's saying it um which is that we'll probably see a new regime in Iran uh so and maybe even in 2025 certainly in the next few years”

0.52

American power or the exercise of American power is based on two things: presidential instinct (the president makes daily choices on matters of war and peace and issues the bureaucracy cannot decide), and the bureaucracy which handles approximately 80% of foreign policy.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“the other thing that nobody writes about or talks about but which is 80% of foreign policy and that's the bureaucracy not just the secretaries of state and defense but the uh the deputy secretaries the under secretaries the assistant secretaries”

0.52

Decline of American power is not inevitable; America could decline while still increasing its power relative to Russia and China, which are in even steeper decline, because decline is relative and there is no absolute standard—all great powers are currently declining and will lead to more chaos rather than a fairer or better world.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“it's absolutely not inevitable I make two points in the piece that America definitely is in Decline but also I point out that China is in a steeper Decline and that Russia is in an even steeper decline so decline is relative America could Decline and yet its power Visa Russia and China even under terrible leadership could increase because it's all relative there is no absolute here so we're really facing a world where all the great powers are declining”

0.52

American power exercised through foreign policy is based on two things: presidential instinct (the president's choices on war, peace, and unresolved bureaucratic questions) and the bureaucracy, which handles 80% of foreign policy.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“I think as American power or the exercise of American power is based on two things one which most people grasp but not enough which is it's based on presidential Instinct the president makes choices a number of choices a day on issues that of great issues of War and Peace and also many issues that the bureaucracy cannot decide upon and gets kicked up to the White House”

0.52

One major threat of a second Trump term is that money has taken over the presidency and will determine policy, as evidenced by Elon Musk's influence despite his wealth, wanting to determine policy as well.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“one of the threats of a second Trump term is that money has taken over the presidency and all about it look at Elon Musk I I mean you know it's not enough that he's worth $50 billion or so but he has to determine policy as well”

0.51

China is in a steeper decline than America, and Russia is in an even steeper decline than both.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“China is in a steeper Decline and that Russia is in an even steeper decline”

0.50

American history shows other upheavals that were seen as the end of the world at the time but in fact led to a rebirth of American statehood.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“then we had other in es I won't go into where um you had other upheavals that were seen as the end of the world at the time but in fact led to a rebirth of American statehood”

0.48

When referring to chaos or anarchy in the context of declining American power, the speaker means not just political crises (like 'chaos at 10 Downing Street') but the literal absence of government authority where militias have guns and roadblocks, like in Kinshasa, Congo, or Haiti.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“chaos or Anarchy are words that are overused in the media I mean the you know if there's a crisis at 10 Downing Street there's chaos that's all nonsense it's utter nonsense when I mean chaos I I mean driving outside the capital of kinaza and the Congo and there's no government there are just militias with guns and roadblocks I'm talking about the kind of chaos where people don't worry about politics they just worry about the safety of themselves and their children”

0.48

There is already significant chaos and state collapse in many regions, but it is not widely written about because it is beyond the media's radar screen and is treated as a normal way of doing things, with Haiti being an extreme example written about only occasionally.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“we'll see more of that I think we there's already a lot of it but it's not written about because it's beyond the radar screen you know essentially you know it's almost a normal way of doing things like Haiti is an extreme example so we read about it but only occasionally”

0.47

When the speaker uses the word 'chaos,' he means genuine anarchy like in Kinshasa, Congo, where there are militias with guns and roadblocks and no government, not the loose media usage of 'chaos' to describe crises at 10 Downing Street.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“chaos or Anarchy are words that are overused in the media I mean the you know if there's a crisis at 10 Downing Street there's chaos that's all nonsense it's utter nonsense when I mean chaos I I mean driving outside the capital of kinaza and the Congo and there's no government there are just militias with guns and roadblocks I'm talking about the kind of chaos where people don't worry about politics they just worry about the safety of themselves and their children”

0.47

American decline is absolutely not inevitable; it is relative decline, and America could decline while its power relative to Russia and China could increase because all decline is relative and not absolute.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“if we're talking about about an Empire falling you said that the US has been an Empire since 1945 is its decline inevitable can it be stopped if someone decided to it's absolutely not inevitable I make two points in the piece that America definitely is in Decline but also I point out that China is in a steeper Decline and that Russia is in an even steeper decline so decline is relative America could Decline and yet its power Visa Russia and China even under terrible leadership could increase because it's all relative there is no absolute here”

0.45

The speaker does not discount the possibility that the very shock of Trumpism could lead to a new birth of American democracy.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“I don't discount the possibility that just the very shock of trumpism could lead to a new birth of American democracy”

0.42

To avoid the fate of decline and chaos, radical new leadership is needed, though the speaker is not discounting completely the possibility that upheaval under Trump could give America a new start.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“what needs to change is some radical new leadership um and it's possible I'm not discounting it completely that that you know that the upheaval under Trump could give America a new start”

0.41

The very shock of Trumpism could lead to a new birth of American democracy.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“I don't discount the possibility that just the very shock of trumpism could lead to a new birth of American democracy”

0.39

What needs to change to avoid American decline is some radical new leadership, which is possible because American history shows repeated upheavals that were seen as the end of the world at the time but led to rebirths of American statehood.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“what needs to change to avoid that fate that you've laid out that possibility when you get a slide like this where you can identify the problems but you don't know what to do about it um what needs to change is some radical new leadership um and it's possible I'm not discounting it completely that that you know that the upheaval under Trump could give America a new start because remember if you look at American history we had the founders who were basic and their sons who were the first six presidents then there was a dramatic change with the seventh president when Andrew Jackson replaced John Quincy Adams”

0.39

America was great in the print and typewriter age, from the founding fathers through the 1960s-1980s, when something changed and America became a pure democracy.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“America was a great um printon typewriter age Empire because most of its history was under what I call the greater print and typewriter age from the founding fathers all the way to take a take a pick 1960s 1970s 1980s essentially then something happened America became a pure democracy”

0.35

Most empires throughout history have declined primarily because of economic reasons or reasons indirectly related to economic causes.

factualestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“most Empires throughout history have decline because of economic reasons and because of reasons related indirectly to economic reasons”

0.34

Had party leaders still been in power in 2016, Trump would never have been the Republican nominee; instead Jeb Bush would have been the Republican nominee and would have become a very good president like his father.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“had the party leaders made those still been in power in 2017 in 2016 Trump never would have been the Republican nominee Jeb Bush would have been the Republican nominee and he would have go gone on to be a a very good president like his father not like his brother”

0.32

The effect of money in Congress and the White House is a major threat to American governance.

factualcontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“it's it's the effect of money in um in Congress in the White House”

0.26

America was a 'great print and typewriter age Empire' for most of its history from the founding fathers to approximately the 1960s-1980s, after which something changed and America became a pure democracy.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“America was a great um printon typewriter age Empire because most of its history was under what I call the greater print and typewriter age from the founding fathers all the way to take a take a pick 1960s 1970s 1980s essentially then something happened America became a pure democracy”

0.26

The effect of money in Congress and the White House represents a major threat to American governance.

factualcontestednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“so that's what I worry about it's it's it's the effect of money in um in Congress in the White House”

0.26

Jimmy Carter was the weakest president of those from Harry Truman to George H.W. Bush in terms of presidential instinct on foreign policy, despite recent positive assessments of his presidency.

factualcontestednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“Jimmy Carter who just died it was actually the weakest of those presidents in terms of presidential Instinct on foreign policy despite all the great things that have been written about him in the past two weeks he was the weakest”

0.25

Equality does not necessarily lead to capability or effectiveness in governance.

definitionspeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“but you know equality doesn't lead to to capability necessarily”

0.25

American history has seen other upheavals (unspecified) that were seen as the end of the world at the time but actually led to a rebirth of American statehood.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“then we had other in es I won't go into where um you had other upheavals that were seen as the end of the world at the time but in fact led to a rebirth of American statehood”

0.24

Regarding presidential instinct decisions (the other 20% of foreign policy), Trump is very unpredictable because he has no well-thought-out worldview, so the outcome could go either way.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“as far as the presidential Instinct decisions that could go in either way Trump is very unpredictable because he has no well-thought out world viw”

0.21

Trump is a 'world historical figure' because he is so different than anyone else, making him difficult to categorize within the normal framework of presidential quality assessment.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“then there's Trump you know who is a world historical figure because he's so different than anyone else”

0.19

Trump is described as a 'world historical figure' because he is so different from everyone else, unlike the conventional weak or mediocre presidents.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Unidentified Speaker — Trump, US decline, and global chaos - Robert D Kaplan inter… [wad8J2hRdpo]

“then there's Trump you know who is a world historical figure because he's so different than anyone else”

0.13

A new regime in Iran will probably emerge in 2025 or certainly within the next few years.

forecastspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Unknown Speaker (Author/Analyst)

“one thing we're going to see probably I've been saying this for 20 years now everybody's saying it um which is that we'll probably see a new regime in Iran uh so and maybe even in 2025 certainly in the next few years”