Progressive consumption tax
A tax levied on what people spend rather than what they earn, with higher rates applied to higher levels of consumption.
As defined in Conversations With Tyler 2022 Retrospective
Other definitions
A tax levied on consumption (rather than income) with rates that rise with the amount consumed, designed to preserve progressivity while not penalizing saving.
Greg Mankiw on Gasoline Taxes, Keynes and Macroeconomics 1/22/2007
Where it comes up · 4
- Robert Frank on Inequality 11/15/20108 claims
- Robert Frank on Success and Luck2 claims
- Conversations With Tyler 2022 Retrospective1 claim
- Greg Mankiw on Gasoline Taxes, Keynes and Macroeconomics 1/22/20071 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 12Search all claims for “Progressive consumption tax” →
- A progressive consumption tax operates much like the income tax but taxes income minus savings minus a large standard deduction (e.g. $30,000 for a family of four), with low rates that escalate slowly until very high spending levels (millions per year) where the marginal rate can be set arbitrarily high without negative effects because such spending is overwhelmingly positional.Robert Frank on Success and Luck
- A steeply progressive consumption tax, phased in gradually, would cause consumption to decline as a share of national income while investment grows, raising productivity and income growth, so that in the new steady state the absolute consumption path would be higher than under the current trajectory, meaning people would eventually get even more of the goods they enjoy.Robert Frank on Success and Luck
- Unlike elk, humans can change the rules of competition, so society could replace the progressive income tax with a progressive consumption tax, measured as income minus saving, with a standard deduction and steeply rising rates on high consumption.Robert Frank on Inequality 11/15/2010
- Inequality of consumption is more troubling than inequality of income, and a progressive consumption tax should replace the progressive income tax: people report income, subtract documented saving, take a large standard deduction (about 30,000 dollars for a family of four), and pay rising rates on the remainder.Robert Frank on Inequality 11/15/2010
- Frank argues that the consumption tax is better than an income tax because it targets consumption inequality, which he considers more troubling than income inequality, and a progressive consumption tax would steer more dollars into venture capital and reduce competitive spending.Robert Frank on Inequality 11/15/2010
- Consumption inequality is more troubling than income inequality, and a progressive consumption tax, in which people report income, subtract savings, apply a large standard deduction, and face steeply rising rates on consumption, would be preferable to a progressive income tax.Robert Frank on Inequality 11/15/2010
- Mankiw's preferred high-impact reforms, ignoring political realism, are: higher Pigouvian taxes; fundamental tax reform along the lines of the president's panel (ideally a broad-based progressive consumption tax); and a very significant but very gradual increase in the retirement age for Social Security and Medicare, on the logic that people are living longer and healthier and shouldn't go on the government dole at the same age as their grandparents.Greg Mankiw on Gasoline Taxes, Keynes and Macroeconomics 1/22/2007
- A progressive consumption tax would discourage wealthy households from spending on status goods such as a $10 million coming-of-age party or an oversized mansion, because high-income households would have an incentive to shelter income in tax-free savings accounts that grow over time.Robert Frank on Inequality 11/15/2010
- The ideal tax system is a progressive consumption tax with a relatively light rate of taxation on capital income—which cannot be zero, because otherwise people will reclassify their labor income as capital income.Conversations With Tyler 2022 Retrospective
- A progressive consumption tax with a steeply rising rate would lead wealthy people to shelter income in tax-free accounts and invest it, which Frank argues serves rich, middle and poor alike because it reduces the costly status spending of high earners.Robert Frank on Inequality 11/15/2010