Positive-Sum
An interaction in which the total available value (the 'pie') can grow so all parties can gain simultaneously, the insight Harari attributes to Adam Smith.
As defined in Yuval Harari on Sapiens
Other definitions
Economic or strategic interaction where both parties gain value—characteristic of maritime trade where both buyer and seller benefit, contrasted with zero-sum territorial conquest
The Geopolitics and History of Continental and Maritime Power - S.C.M. PaineA situation or activity where one party's gain does not require another party's loss, so total value is created rather than transferred.
David Senra - In Service of Founders - [Invest Like the Best, EP.343]
Where it comes up · 11
- Pete Buttigieg on 2024 and the ‘Crank Realignment’1 claim
- Ezra Klein & Derek Thompson - Abundance Is the Key to Fixing America | Prof G Conversations1 claim
- #435: Mark Zuckerberg’s Empire1 claim
- School’s Out For Summer1 claim
- #345 George Lucas1 claim
- #98 Enzo Ferrari (the making of an automobile empire)1 claim
- Nathan Nunn1 claim
- Tyler Cowen on Inequality, the Future, and Average is Over1 claim
and 3 more
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “Positive-Sum” →
- For most of history people experienced the world as zero-sum, believing one person or kingdom could grow richer only by making another poorer, but Adam Smith and others introduced the revolutionary—simultaneously economic, ethical, and religious—idea that the whole pie can grow so everyone can profit at once; this insight has so far proven correct for humans even if not for other animals, yet remains very hard to grasp.Yuval Harari on Sapiens
- Entrepreneurship is positive-sum because many businesses can succeed simultaneously, whereas racing and athletics are zero-sum because only one person can win the championship, which is why Ferrari shifted toward business.#98 Enzo Ferrari (the making of an automobile empire)
- Trust increases with education and (over a hump-shaped range) with income, but the deeper remedy for low trust is economic growth itself: when growth makes activities positive-sum rather than zero-sum, people have more frequent successful interactions, learn they can trust one another, and realize the benefits of cooperation, creating a virtuous but chicken-and-egg cycle between development and trust.Nathan Nunn
- For most of human history wealth was built by taking from others through conquest, theft, and plunder, whereas modern entrepreneurship is positive-sum because it creates value that does not take from anyone else.David Senra - In Service of Founders - [Invest Like the Best, EP.343]
- Globalization equalizes wage rates across countries through an arbitrage applied to the price of labor much like the price of apples, so that while global inequality falls sharply, within virtually every country inequality rises and median wages slightly decline, with much of the effect being zero-sum rather than purely positive-sum.Tyler Cowen on Inequality, the Future, and Average is Over
- Zuckerberg says Augustus's key contribution was teaching society that you need not always be at war, rewiring the economy away from a massive standing army toward trade, which was a positive-sum choice that required courage.#435: Mark Zuckerberg’s Empire
- When Spielberg first saw Lucas's THX 1138 and said he hated the director because he was so much better, the two reframed their rivalry as positive-sum, since one filmmaker's success did not reduce the other's chance to succeed, and they became collaborators.#345 George Lucas
- The maritime order is positive-sum (both parties to trade win) while the continental order is negative-sum (winner's gain less than loser's loss because conquered territories are damaged), making the maritime order the only sustainable model for long-term human prosperity.NWC 2025 INS Lecture - Dr. Sarah Paine: Geopolitics, Cold War Lessons and the Way Forward
- Right-wing populism thrives on scarcity—suspicion of the rest of the world, immigrants, and other nations—with the belief that trade cannot be positive-sum and that cooperation weakens rather than strengthens a country.Ezra Klein & Derek Thompson - Abundance Is the Key to Fixing America | Prof G Conversations
- Both positive-sum and zero-sum claims about the economy can be true simultaneously—there is competition between countries for factories and jobs (supporting zero-sum framing) but also potential for the pie to grow bigger (supporting positive-sum framing), and American workers have been promised the pie would get bigger without realizing their slices wouldn't.Pete Buttigieg on 2024 and the ‘Crank Realignment’