Payment for Order Flow
The practice where a broker receives compensation for routing customer orders to particular firms or market makers for execution.
As defined in 271 - Earning To Give
Other definitions
A model where a retail broker receives a small per-share rebate from a market maker in exchange for routing customer orders to it
Robinhood: Mobile First, Margins Later
Where it comes up · 6
- Robinhood: Mobile First, Margins Later7 claims
- Interactive Brokers: Margin Masters3 claims
- Wall Street’s Art Critic2 claims
- Vlad Tenev - Navigating Robinhood's Evolution - [Invest Like the Best, EP.384]2 claims
- 271 - Earning To Give1 claim
- Sam Bankman-Fried - Creating a Perfect Market - [Invest Like the Best, EP. 247]1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 16Search all claims for “Payment for Order Flow” →
- Robinhood's founders believed traditional brokers earned about 30% of revenue from commissions, so a clean-sheet modern brokerage could run far more efficiently with no branches, legacy workflows, and smaller headcount, harvesting expense savings to offset the lost commission revenue while making up the difference through customer volume and other revenue lines.Robinhood: Mobile First, Margins Later
- Crypto differs fundamentally from traditional finance because the entire financial stack—clearing, settlement, risk, compliance, KYC, mobile app, API, matching engine—is collapsed into a single product, the exchange, so that the average transaction involves only buyer, seller, and exchange, whereas buying a stock routes through roughly 12 companies.271 - Earning To Give
- Payment for order flow is much cheaper for small trades: a $1,000 trade that would bear about 200 basis points of commission-based cost may bear only about 1 to 2 basis points under payment for order flow, with a rough break-even near $50,000 to $100,000 per trade above which it becomes more expensive for customers.Robinhood: Mobile First, Margins Later
- Since day one IBKR has used direct market access, linking to nearly every exchange so it executes at the best price for clients; by avoiding payment for order flow it avoids the hidden cost that PFOF imposes on customers' execution prices, yet still provides lower commissions than rivals.Interactive Brokers: Margin Masters
- Net interest margin has overtaken transaction revenue as Robinhood's largest revenue contributor, because in the zero-rate era payment for order flow dominated, but higher rates have shifted the mix toward cash and asset-building products.Vlad Tenev - Navigating Robinhood's Evolution - [Invest Like the Best, EP.384]
- In payment for order flow, a broker receives a small rebate from a market maker such as Citadel in exchange for routing retail orders, because retail flow is seen as non-toxic and uncorrelated, and market makers earn tiny per-share spreads that aggregate to significant profit.Robinhood: Mobile First, Margins Later
- Payment for order flow is pretty much only a US phenomenon, and the businesses that buy order flow earn large profits that must come out of someone's wallet, implicitly from the customer's execution price.Interactive Brokers: Margin Masters
- Academic studies on payment for order flow are roughly split: about half find it slightly harms execution quality and half find no impact, so the policy debate is less settled than critics such as Gary Gensler suggest.Robinhood: Mobile First, Margins Later
- Payment for order flow exists because trades must pass through many separate companies, such as app, custodian, ATS, prime broker, and exchange, and PFOF firms glue these together by pricing each handoff.Sam Bankman-Fried - Creating a Perfect Market - [Invest Like the Best, EP. 247]
- The founders observed that their HFT firm was trading thousands of times a day while paying nothing or effectively being rebated, whereas retail investors paid roughly $10 per trade, which they viewed as rent-seeking that should be disrupted.Robinhood: Mobile First, Margins Later