NEPA
The U.S. National Environmental Policy Act, here invoked as an example of lengthy regulatory reporting requirements that slow construction.
As defined in Zvi Mowshowitz on AI and the Dial of Progress
Where it comes up · 8
- Brian Potter - Future of Construction, Ugly Modernism, & Environmental Review5 claims
- CHIPS Act: Securing Semiconductor Supply1 claim
- Nvidia v. Google, Scaling Laws, and the Economics of AI1 claim
- China is killing the US on energy. Does that mean they’ll win AGI? — Casey Handmer1 claim
- Zvi Mowshowitz on AI and the Dial of Progress1 claim
- Eli Dourado - Frontiers for Productivity - [Invest Like the Best, EP. 225]1 claim
- Derek Thompson1 claim
- Leopold Aschenbrenner — 2027 AGI, China/US super-intelligence race, & the return of history1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 12Search all claims for “NEPA” →
- Environmental rules of the 1960s-70s came in two kinds: outcome regulations (Clean Air and Water Acts setting pollution limits) that achieved exactly what was wanted, and process regulations (NEPA) that empowered citizens to sue and demand environmental reviews; process regulation is more prone to abuse because the same rules that protected the environment are now ironically used to block clean energy and dense housing, hurting the environment in the 2020s.Derek Thompson
- Imposing maximum timelines on NEPA processes could backfire because the 'hard look' doctrine requires thoroughly considering impacts; if a cap forces approval before, say, a species' two-week flowering observation window, opponents can litigate that the agency 'didn't look hard enough,' increasing susceptibility to litigation rather than speeding projects—and since agencies already exceed the 150-page statutory limit (averaging 660 pages) out of risk aversion, fixes that don't address the underlying incentives will fail.Brian Potter - Future of Construction, Ugly Modernism, & Environmental Review
- NEPA is a horribly drafted law containing no provisions for funding or enforcement; the impact-statement requirement, added late without fanfare, became the most important part only because an activist-era court chose to enforce it strongly—so NEPA's court-enforced, citizen-lawsuit structure is an accident of path dependency, not how any country would design environmental protection from scratch.Brian Potter - Future of Construction, Ugly Modernism, & Environmental Review
- NEPA opponents can't permanently stop a project (only thorough documentation is required) but can sue to slow it down, and if slowed enough the project becomes unattractive and gets canceled—which is what many groups hope for—creating uncertainty that makes businesses deliberately avoid projects where they can't predict NEPA's duration or cost.Brian Potter - Future of Construction, Ugly Modernism, & Environmental Review
- Society collectively makes a single 'dial' decision about how much to allow people to do things versus require permissions, regulations, and veto points; the U.S. has moved from open-field freedom toward pervasive permission regimes that make innovation hard, and crucially people treat this as one dial—every new restriction strengthens the precautionary faction and rhetoric, making it easier to regulate everything else, while every freedom seen working strengthens the case for more freedom.Zvi Mowshowitz on AI and the Dial of Progress
- To build AGI infrastructure at scale in the US, the nation has two main paths: (1) increase natural gas production (the US can double production again in 7 years, providing enough power for multiple trillion-dollar data centers), or (2) pursue green energy megaprojects (solar, batteries, SMRs, geothermal) coupled with massive deregulation (FERC reform, NEPA exemptions, streamlined state permitting).Leopold Aschenbrenner — 2027 AGI, China/US super-intelligence race, & the return of history
- NEPA requires any major federal action with significant environmental impacts to undergo a long, thorough, expensive environmental impact study—averaging around four and a half years, with some taking longer (the highway administration needed eight and a half years for one statement)—functioning effectively as a tax on major government actions that reduces how much gets done.Brian Potter - Future of Construction, Ugly Modernism, & Environmental Review
- The National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 requires federal agencies to document environmental impacts or prove there are none before acting, which has become roughly a five-year process to document impacts and about two years to prove absence, delaying projects such as tunnels and hyperloop networks.Eli Dourado - Frontiers for Productivity - [Invest Like the Best, EP. 225]
- Nuclear power cannot be built quickly in America because of permitting rules such as NEPA, so the near-term solutions are natural gas and solar, with data centers located near gas basins such as Abilene.Nvidia v. Google, Scaling Laws, and the Economics of AI
- NEPA is 'anti-law' because laws serve two purposes—encouraging/discouraging behavior, and reducing coordination problems—and NEPA does neither: it's purely a documentation requirement that doesn't prevent environmental harm (you can do anything if documented thoroughly) and it worsens coordination by creating uncertainty since requirements are unclear, definitions of environmental effects shift over time, and litigation can delay projects indefinitely.Brian Potter - Future of Construction, Ugly Modernism, & Environmental Review