Muslim Brotherhood
A transnational Islamist organization; in Palestine its lineage produced both Hamas and the very different politics of Mansour Abbas.
As defined in Year Zero of the Arab-Israeli Conflict (with Hillel Cohen)
Where it comes up · 17
- Sam Harris on Jew-Hatred, Radical Islam, and the West2 claims
- 438 - More From Sam Israel-hamas Deal Qatari Air Force Base Trump Charlie Kirk Ezra Klein2 claims
- 50 - The Borders Of Tolerance2 claims
- 55 - Islamism Vs Secularism2 claims
- 422 - Zionism Jihadism2 claims
- How Israel Used “SPONGE BOMBS” in Hamas' Tunnels2 claims
- The Man Who Would Be King of Saudi Arabia (with Karen Elliott House)1 claim
- Year Zero of the Arab-Israeli Conflict (with Hillel Cohen)1 claim
and 9 more
Most important claims · 10 of 23Search all claims for “Muslim Brotherhood” →
- Al-Qaeda could not be understood as an acute group of psychopaths to be cut out, but only as the last chapter of a 60-year history running from post-colonial pan-Arabism through its failure under Nasser, the radicalization of the Muslim Brotherhood and Zawahiri, the anti-Soviet fight, and the Gulf War, after which it degenerated into a death cult—and the domestic extremist threat must be understood the same way, by going back 100-200 years to grasp why people are willing to risk their lives, so that the fringe can be de-radicalized.231 - Crossing The Abyss
- Islam, uniquely among the monotheisms, was born as a conquering empire and so early came to treat geopolitical success as evidence of being in sync with God's plan; therefore when Muslim civilization found itself weak and 'backward' under 19th-century European dominance, theologians interpreted this weakness as a signal of distance from God, producing a pietistic movement of return to original Islam as the path back to power—a lineage running from al-Afghani through Abduh, Rida, and al-Banna to the Muslim Brotherhood and Hamas.422 - Zionism Jihadism
- ISIS worked hard to ensure ideological uniformity through an educational project where belief in specific doctrines marked membership, whereas Hamas is theologically flexible to the point of accepting nationalists, which ISIS would consider grounds for killing them; Hamas attackers used jihadist slogans but many participants' motives ranged widely.339 - The Infernal Logic Of Jihad
- In Islamist thinking, Zionism is seen as the worst of all the indignities Islam suffered because the Jews were weak refugees—'the weakest thing that ever pushed islam back'—so overcoming the Jews and reclaiming what was lost becomes the necessary first step in Islam's return to its rightful redemptive place in history, making Hamas's war about overcoming the Jews rather than liberating Palestine or creating an independent Palestinian state.422 - Zionism Jihadism
- Palestinian failure to empathize with Zionism is driven by living under occupation, not by living in a police state; comparing Hamas to Knesset member Mansour Abbas—both from the Muslim Brotherhood, reading the same texts—shows that the difference in their acceptance of a Jewish state tracks whether one lives in relative equality (as an Israeli citizen) or under occupation.Year Zero of the Arab-Israeli Conflict (with Hillel Cohen)
- ISIS is fundamentally incorrigible because it is a pure expression of religious certainty oriented toward an international caliphate and a 7th-century vision including slavery, whereas Hamas is an Islamist-inflected outgrowth of a Palestinian national-liberation movement and the Muslim Brotherhood tied to specific territory, making Hamas capable of the kind of pragmatic moderation ISIS is not.356 - Islam Freedom
- A durable peace and war of ideas within Islam against jihadism and Islamism is a huge generational project; even if Gulf rulers like MBS rein in fanaticism, there remains a tension with the 'Arab street' and the source code of Islam, plus jihadist threats in Western Europe, so the project of purging jihadist orientation across 100 countries will not be completed within the lifetimes of anyone listening.438 - More From Sam Israel-hamas Deal Qatari Air Force Base Trump Charlie Kirk Ezra Klein
- When Abdel Fattah el-Sisi came to power in Egypt, he eliminated the Muslim Brotherhood's influence, meaning Hamas no longer had an ally in Egypt that was willing to keep the tunnels open, and el-Sisi has invested in bulldozing the tunnels into Egypt, weakening a Gazan economy that is already struggling due to Israeli sanctions and Israel's own efforts to demolish the tunnel network.How Israel Used “SPONGE BOMBS” in Hamas' Tunnels
- Mohammed Morsi, the former Egyptian leader and Muslim Brotherhood member, had ties that allowed him to keep tunnels from Egypt to Gaza open for smuggling operations for years.How Israel Used “SPONGE BOMBS” in Hamas' Tunnels
- Qatar, governed by Muslim Brotherhood theology (of which Hamas is an offshoot), has given more money to Western universities than any other country, and funds protest-organizing groups like Students for Justice in Palestine (via American Muslims for Palestine) and Jewish Voice for Peace, amounting to a decades-long psyop and malicious exercise of soft power over Western education that has been tolerated because money and oil are irresistible.367 - Campus Protests Antisemitism And Western Values