Meritocracy
A system that allocates rewards and status based on perceived merit and effort, which Sapolsky argues rests on the false premise that people deserve outcomes they had no control over.
As defined in et_916
Other definitions
A system of social organization in which advancement and rewards are allocated based on individual talent, effort, and achievement rather than on the basis of wealth, privilege, or family connections
Why meritocracy is a LIE... (it's way worse than people realize)
Where it comes up · 34
- Meritocracy, economic turmoil, and the broken promises of the West | Daniel Markovits FULL INTERVIEW17 claims
- Why meritocracy is a LIE... (it's way worse than people realize)8 claims
- 221 - Success Failure The Common Good6 claims
- World On Fire: The Root Causes of Populism, Authoritarianism and The Whole Global Mess4 claims
- David Brooks Interview: How To Live A Meaningful Life3 claims
- Living Through Revolutionary Times2 claims
- A Perspective with Malcolm Gladwell2 claims
- Luigi Zingales on Capitalism and Crony Capitalism2 claims
and 26 more
Most important claims · 10 of 77Search all claims for “Meritocracy” →
- The history of meritocratic systems shows a pattern of inevitably becoming more insular over time—exemplified by ancient China's meritocratic system where elites began special training their children for the civil service exams, reproducing the exact problem meritocracy was supposed to solveMeritocracy, economic turmoil, and the broken promises of the West | Daniel Markovits FULL INTERVIEW
- Dutch researcher Jonathan Mijs found empirically that the more unequal a country is, the more its inhabitants believe in meritocracy, demonstrating a counterintuitive relationship between inequality and meritocracy belief.Why meritocracy is a LIE... (it's way worse than people realize)
- Jonathan Mijs calls the relationship between inequality and meritocracy belief 'The Paradox of Inequality,' a profound discovery that when countries are more unequal, people believe more strongly in meritocracy despite research showing these unequal countries have lower social mobility.Why meritocracy is a LIE... (it's way worse than people realize)
- Advantage under meritocracy is distributed based on accomplishment, which depends on three inputs: natural ability, effort, and training. While natural ability and effort are more randomly distributed across the population, training is where the wealthy secure unjust advantage—the elite that reached its position through meritocratic means has unmatched willingness and resources to invest in training its children.Meritocracy, economic turmoil, and the broken promises of the West | Daniel Markovits FULL INTERVIEW
- Meritocracy must be reconceived because the meritorious had no hand in becoming so, yet competence still matters—we genuinely want skilled neurosurgeons and soccer players, and we cannot pretend not to care about differential ability and effort; the problem is not demanding competence but that opportunities to acquire competence are radically unequally distributed and that competence breeds a false sense of being a more deserving human.360 - We Really Don T Have Free Will
- The English language term 'made redundant' (meaning fired) captures the exact problem with market-based systems: it literally means 'declared worthless' or 'surplus to requirements', and this is the implicit status message of market-based meritocracy even when no one consciously believes in moral desertMeritocracy, economic turmoil, and the broken promises of the West | Daniel Markovits FULL INTERVIEW
- For every scarce position of wealth and power maintained within families already possessing wealth and power across generations, there is one less position available to someone from a family without wealth and power to climb into, directly reducing social mobility.Why meritocracy is a LIE... (it's way worse than people realize)
- The educated class lost credibility not only because of mistakes (Iraq War, financial crisis) but because they created and benefited from systems of meritocracy that widened the social chasm: by age 3, affluent parents send kids to preschool at twice the rate as less affluent families; by age 6, affluent children are 4 grade levels ahead; by age 18, a child in the top 20% of earners has a 1-in-5 chance of scoring over 1400 on the SAT while a child in the bottom 20% has a 1-in-50 chance.How America Recovers from All This | Yale Conversations with David Brooks | Yale University
- Democracy makes no sense for solving problems once a goal is agreed—you let an expert pilot land the plane or an expert doctor treat the disease rather than voting—but democracy is essential precisely because in most cases we do not agree on what the problems and goals are, and on questions of priorities and values there is no reason to give experts more authority than anyone else.138 - The Edge Of Humanity
- When inequality of outcomes becomes large enough, equality of opportunity becomes impossible regardless of the system, because those with the most power use their privilege and resources to secure opportunities for their children within or against the systemMeritocracy, economic turmoil, and the broken promises of the West | Daniel Markovits FULL INTERVIEW