Robert Sapolsky on Determinism, Free Will, and Responsibility
What this covers
Robert Sapolsky, a neuroscientist, joins Russ Roberts for a conversation on determinism, free will, and moral responsibility. Sapolsky develops a thoroughgoing argument that human behavior emerges from a Seamless Causal Arc stretching backward through neurons, hormones, childhood, fetal development, genes, and ancestral culture—territory over which no individual exercised control. From this premise he draws a stark conclusion: if we are nothing but the sum of biology and environment we did not choose, it makes no sense to blame, punish, praise, or reward anyone. The two examine what follows logically—the dismantling of criminal justice systems and meritocracy—and wrestle with how to live if free will is illusory.
Sapolsky addresses major counterarguments. Quantum indeterminacy offers no escape because randomness is not agency, and chaotic systems remain deterministic even when unpredictable. The Symmetry of Blame and Praise means that if we cannot blame people for bad acts, we cannot credit them for good ones either. On historical grounds, Sapolsky argues that removing blame for conditions once deemed moral failings—epilepsy, schizophrenia, dyslexia—has made society kinder, not chaotic, suggesting we can extend Subtracting Blame to all behavior. The conversation also covers concrete mechanisms: how maternal socioeconomic stress shapes fetal brain development, how Culture of Honor emerges among nomadic pastoralists rather than farmers, and how post hoc confabulation masks the real sensory and biological drivers of our choices. Roberts pushes back on both the scope of empirical claims and the practical implications, but the two find common ground on what justice reform should prioritize if determinism is true.
Sapolsky argues that human behavior is entirely the product of biology and environment over which we had no control—a seamless deterministic arc from one second to a million years before any act—so free will is an illusion and it never makes sense to blame, punish, praise, or reward anyone.
- Asking where intent 'comes from' reveals an unbroken causal chain (neurons, hormones, childhood, fetal life, genes, ancestral culture) with no crack for free will
- Quantum indeterminacy and emergence offer no escape—they produce randomness, not agency
- Removing the sense of responsibility for behaviors (epilepsy, dyslexia, schizophrenia) has historically made the world kinder, not more chaotic
Behavior traces seamlessly to genes, development, and environment across evolutionary and individual timescales with no gap for free will.
- Behavior is the product of a single seamless arc of biology interacting with environment—genes implying millions of years of evolution, proteins made minutes ago, hormones, childhood, fetal life, and ancestral culture—over none of which we had control, and there is no crack in this arc where free will or a causeless cause could be inserted.
“It's this seamless arc of biology--over which you had no control--interacting with environment--over which you had no control. And, when you look at this seamless arc, there's not a crack in it anywhere in which you can shoehorn in free will”
- Quantum indeterminacy cannot rescue free will for three reasons: quantal events are far too tiny to plausibly bubble up to affect neurons in a coordinated way; even if they did, they would produce randomness rather than free will, whereas we observe consistency of character; and the idea that a nebulous 'you' could reach down and shape quantum effects is unconvincing hand-waving.
“this is not a mechanism for free will. It's a mechanism for randomness. And, we're not really interested in randomness.”
- Legal and scientific debates about free will focus too narrowly on proximal intent (did the person intend the act, know consequences, know alternatives); the only interesting question is where that intent came from, and answering it opens a causal chain stretching from one second to a million years before the behavior.
“asking where did the intent to do that come from opens up a massive portal”
- Appealing to someone being a 'mature, competent adult' to preserve free will fails because when two such adults face the same temptation and one resists while the other doesn't, you must ask where each one's capacity for self-discipline came from—and it traces to childhood, genetic predispositions to thrill-seeking, and prior social experiences, all outside their control.
“where did the person's intent to resist come from, and where did the other person's intent to resist fail?”
- The biggest mistake people make in inferring free will from chaos is conflating unpredictability with indeterminism: non-linear, chaotic, emergent systems mean we will never have full predictive power (we can't say which of three kids in a bad environment becomes a murderer, only that they are 47 times more likely than a suburban kid), but the absence of prediction does not mean there were no causal gears—it just means we don't know how they work.
“Just because the world is not predictable, doesn't mean the world is not deterministic.”
Unconscious biological and environmental influences shape moral judgment and behavior before conscious reasoning occurs.
- When people fill out questionnaires in a room with a foul smell, they become on average more socially conservative—more likely to view different others' actions as disturbing or wrong—while their economic and geopolitical views are unaffected, and this effect is entirely unconscious; conversely, the smell of fresh cookies makes people more generous in economic games.
“when you put people in a room with a bad smell, people on the average become more socially conservative. It doesn't affect their economic views, their geopolitical views.”
- Cross-cultural studies show reliable differences in how long an infant cries before its mother picks it up depending on the culture's ancestral ecology, so a person's brain is being differently shaped by the world within minutes of birth as a downstream consequence of whether their ancestors were rainforest dwellers or nomadic pastoralists.
“within minutes of birth, there are reliable differences in how long the baby has to cry before on the average, the mother picks them up. And, if you come from a culture where they wait three minutes versus three seconds, your brain is being very differently shaped by the world within minutes of life”
- When people change their judgments due to unconscious influences like a bad smell, they never attribute the change to the real cause; instead they generate a post hoc confabulation, claiming they 'thought about it' and found a genuine reason, masking the actual sensory or biological driver.
“They're going to say, 'I thought about it and I realized this is actually the reason why. Here is the post hoc confabulation I'm going to come up with.'”
- Neuroimaging of fetuses shows that the rate of fetal brain growth is influenced by the mother's socioeconomic status: a poor mother's brain marinates the fetus in stress hormones from her circulation, delaying aspects of brain maturation, so a person's adult brain is already being shaped before birth by their mother's place in society.
“the rate of a fetus's brain growth is influenced by the mother's socioeconomic status. If your mother is poor, a bazillion studies show your brain is more likely to be getting marinated in stress hormones from her circulation. And, that delays aspects of brain maturation.”
- When two people watch the same documentary on the Armenian genocide and one is moved to learn more and extend empathy while the other shrugs, the difference is fully explained by each having a different second-before, hour-before, and lifetime of antecedents—where they learned to read, gained respect for reading, developed attention span, and acquired empathic capacity—none chosen by them.
“Why does one person say, 'I want to learn more about this'? Where do they learn how to read? Where do they get respect for reading as a means for finding out about the world?”
Removing blame from behaviors once deemed moral failures has repeatedly made society kinder without collapse.
- Humanity has repeatedly jettisoned the sense of responsibility for behaviors once thought to be moral failings—epilepsy as consorting with Satan, schizophrenia as bad mothering, dyslexia as laziness, leptin-gene obesity as poor self-discipline—and each time the roof did not cave in; instead the world became kinder, suggesting we can extend this subtraction of blame to all behavior since the line between 'edge cases' and 'us' is artificial.
“At some point, we figured out witches don't really exist. At some point, we figured out that people who have epileptic seizures are not cavorting with Satan at midnight each night.”
- If we are nothing more than the sum of biology and environment over which we had no control, it never makes sense to blame or punish someone—and equally never makes sense to praise or reward them—which logically requires dismantling not only the criminal justice system but the entire meritocracy, since both rest on the false premise that people should be punished or rewarded for things over which they had no control.
“it never ever makes any sense to blame someone or punish someone. And, equally so, it never... To praise them or reward them.”
- Finding the loss of free will demoralizing is itself a marker of privilege: anyone able to read the book or reflect on these ideas is among the lucky who got education, love, clean water, and safety—for the global majority who lack these, being held responsible for things outside their control is the cruelest idea humans invented and a major source of earth's miseries, so determinism is liberating rather than depressing for them.
“For most people on this planet, being held accountable for things that you really had no control over goes in a bad direction.”
- If we were exactly as reflective and compassionate as we are now but living 300 years ago, it would have seemed intuitively obvious that some people are constitutionally suited to be slaves and that enslaving them does them a favor—showing that our moral intuitions are products of their time and that self-evident intuitions can and do change.
“it would have seemed intuitively obvious to us that some people constitutionally are appropriately slaves. And, that in fact, you're doing them a favor by making them slaves”
Determinism permits mechanistic learning and change while precluding desert-based punishment or reward systems.
- A deterministic universe does not mean nothing can change; behavior changes through learning, which is a mechanistic process using the same genes, enzymes, and neurochemicals as when a sea slug learns to fear a shock—the mistake is believing we are the agents who choose to change, when in fact prior circumstances brought about the change in us.
“It's this seamless arc of biology--over which you had no control--interacting with environment--over which you had no control. And, when you look at this seamless arc, there's not a crack in it anywhere in which you can shoehorn in free will”
- Experimental psychology studies show that subtly priming people to believe slightly less in free will makes them more likely to cheat in an online economic game about ten minutes later, but this only reflects a transient effect; people who have long disbelieved in free will and worked through it are exactly as ethical as those who fully believe in agency.
“you take people, and you prime them subtly to believe a little bit less in free will. And, 10 minutes afterward, they're more likely to cheat in an economic game that they're playing online.”
- Both Sapolsky and Roberts agree that differential salaries and not redistributing income can be justified as incentives that produce good outcomes, but not on the grounds that anyone deserves what they have, since no one earns their endowments.
“like that as an incentive, differential salaries, but not because anyone deserves it.”
- Even though emotions reduce entirely to neurotransmitters, genes, and developmental history, they are real for us in the only sense that matters—we are capable of being pained, comforted, or solaced by them—so a person can care about the world and write a book to change minds despite believing free will is an illusion.
“things that feel real for us are actually real insofar as we are capable of being pained by them, or comforted by them, or solaced”
Emergent complexity from sufficient biological quantity generates consciousness, morality, and human distinctiveness.
- A human neuron and a fruit fly neuron are indistinguishable under a microscope, but humans have roughly 100 million neurons for each one a fly has; this sheer quantity produces emergent complexity such that quantity changes quality, yielding theology, aesthetics, and economic systems—and tripling a chimp's neurons (which we have via evolutionary gene duplication) would generate human-like qualities.
“the difference is that we have 100 million neurons for every single one that a fly has. And, you get this thing of an emergent complexity and emergent process that throw enough neurons together, and stuff comes out that defines primate-ness”
- We may be only a few years away from seeing consciousness emerge from artificial intelligence as another instance of quantity producing quality—unexpected things emerge when enough computational power is thrown at a problem, paralleling how human consciousness emerged from sheer neuron count.
“the difference is that we have 100 million neurons for every single one that a fly has. And, you get this thing of an emergent complexity and emergent process that throw enough neurons together, and stuff comes out that defines primate-ness”
- Humans are biological machines like sparrows, crabgrass, and whales, but the unique difference is that we are the only machines that know our own machine-ness, which makes our feelings and intentions real to us; emotions reducible to neurotransmitters and genes still feel real, and because they can pain or comfort us, they are real for us.
“we are biological machines that interact with environment. But, the difference with us is we're the only biological machines that know our machine-ness, and thus can view feelings and intentions for real things; and thus they become real things to us. That's the weirdness of us.”
- Along with the human capacity to know our own ultimate fate and that of our loved ones, evolution had to develop a capacity for self-deception, because confronting the human predicament without it is damaging to people.
“along with that has had to evolve the capacity for self-deception, because a failure of that is a pretty damaging thing to people when they consider the human predicament”
Cultures and moral intuitions are shaped by ancestral ecology and historical circumstances, not universal truths.
- Cultures of honor—with warrior classes and revenge ethics—reliably arise among nomadic pastoralists (herders of camels, cattle, yaks) because their wealth is mobile and can be stolen overnight, making fierce deterrence necessary; they don't arise among hunter-gatherers or farmers whose resources can't be rustled, and this explains why the American South, settled by herding Scots-Irish, has had higher honor-murder rates than the Puritan/Quaker-settled North for centuries.
“Cultures of honor come from people who herd animals--camel people, and cow people, and yak people... people can come out at night and be low-down sneaky varmints and rustle your cattle or steal your camels”
- The literature on whether atheists are less moral than theists shows that people who have thought long and hard about good, evil, and human responsibility are equally ethical regardless of whether they conclude we are biological machines without God or children of God with free will; the least ethical are the apathetic ones in between who never grappled with the question.
“the most ethical people in their behavior are either people who are stridently religious or stridently non-religious. It's the apathetic ones in between, those are the ones who haven't gotten there.”
- Juries readily accept that a single dramatic cause—like a car accident wiping out the frontal cortex at age ten—can destroy behavioral regulation, but they never find it convincing that the same impaired frontal cortex can result from the cumulative effect of many small distributed influences (maternal second-trimester stress hormones, neighborhood safety, culturally instilled revenge norms), even though the biological outcome is identical.
“It is never going to find convincing that second trimester stress hormone levels for mom, and whether it was a safe neighborhood when they were a kid... is going to produce the same exact sort of frontal cortex as something like an accident did”