Legitimacy
The perception by citizens that a government's authority is justified and rightful, making citizens willing to accept its rules and coercion; depends on both effectiveness and fairness
As defined in RSA Replay: Political Order and Political Decay
Other definitions
In political and international contexts, the quality of being perceived as rightful, just, and proper; in this transcript refers to Russia's desire for international recognition of its status and right to great-power treatment
EPC Talks Geopolitics with Sergey Radchenko
Where it comes up · 4
- RSA Replay: Political Order and Political Decay2 claims
- Francis Fukuyama on the War in Ukraine, Authoritarianism, and Liberal Democracy2 claims
- Mark Galeotti - Russia has Defied Predictions of Analysts and Media. What are we Still Getting Wrong1 claim
- EPC Talks Geopolitics with Sergey Radchenko1 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “Legitimacy” →
- Soviet leaders from Stalin through Gorbachev valued status and legitimacy as much as or more than ideology; they desired to be recognized as a great power on the international stage and felt deeply insecure despite their military strength, requiring external validation particularly from the United States.EPC Talks Geopolitics with Sergey Radchenko
- Afghanistan has been undermined because Hamid Karzai and his people are unbelievably corrupt, which undermines the legitimacy of the whole NATO project, and the alliance has not figured out a way of dealing with this.RSA Replay: Political Order and Political Decay
- Putin's legitimacy has been built on success on the battlefield in the context of the Ukraine war, but lacks a deeper reservoir of goodwill that would sustain him if defeated militarily. This contrasts with how autocratic legitimacy is fragile when performance claims fail.Francis Fukuyama on the War in Ukraine, Authoritarianism, and Liberal Democracy
- China's Communist Party legitimacy was similarly built on a claim to competence and superior governance, with COVID handling as exhibit number one, but China has revealed huge weaknesses through inadequate intensive care beds and inadequate healthcare for rural citizens, undercutting its performance legitimacy claim.Francis Fukuyama on the War in Ukraine, Authoritarianism, and Liberal Democracy
- Corruption can smooth transactions in some views, but it is definitely a second-best alternative to having a non-corrupt system in the first place where you don't have to pay bribes; corruption is corrosive of legitimacy in China and has always been corrosive in Chinese history.RSA Replay: Political Order and Political Decay
- Within Russian institutions (particularly education), many people are currently required to voice support for the war and regime while privately dissenting, a pattern that mirrors how Soviet citizens publicly conformed while privately mocking their system; this suggests that surface compliance does not indicate genuine legitimacy.Mark Galeotti - Russia has Defied Predictions of Analysts and Media. What are we Still Getting Wrong