Laplace's demon
A hypothetical entity that, knowing the exact state of every particle, could perfectly predict and retrodict the entire history of the universe.
As defined in AMA | October 2024
Other definitions
A hypothetical intellect that, knowing the exact positions and momenta of all particles, could compute the entire past and future; used to illustrate that concepts like temperature and creativity require incomplete information.
AMA | April 2022
Where it comes up · 36
- 124 - In Search Of Reality5 claims
- AMA | August 20214 claims
- 244 | Katie Elliott on Metaphysics, Chance, and Explanation3 claims
- AMA | April 20213 claims
- Free Will Is Real (with Kevin Mitchell)2 claims
- AMA | April 20242 claims
- AMA | December 20212 claims
- AMA | July 20212 claims
and 28 more
Most important claims · 10 of 54Search all claims for “Laplace's demon” →
- Although modern physics holds that the microscopic information contained in a person persists through time (as in Laplace's demon or the black hole information paradox), this does not constitute immortality, because personal identity is a macroscopic, emergent phenomenon and the accessible information that defines you becomes inaccessible at death.Holiday Message: Reflections on Immortality
- Laplace's demon is a thought experiment of a vast intelligence knowing every particle's position and velocity plus all laws, to which past and future are equally clear, but it crucially does not exist and could never exist; to model the universe it would need to be as complex as the universe itself, so taking it literally as 'a dude who knows a lot of stuff' is deeply misleading.AMA | May 2021
- Newton's deterministic equations relate the configuration of the universe at one moment rigidly to all other moments, which suggests reconceiving time as a coordinate locating you in a four-dimensional spacetime (the eternalist block view) rather than as something that brings about change.300 | Solo: Does Time Exist?
- The popular claim that 'because of quantum mechanics there is no such thing as cause and effect' goes too far; the right response to discovering indeterminism is not to give up on causation, explanation, and prediction but to re-conceptualize them so they make sense in an indeterministic world.244 | Katie Elliott on Metaphysics, Chance, and Explanation
- Emergence is a quasi-magical exception to the general rule of physics: normally if you discard even a little microscopic data you lose all predictive power (e.g., knowing only half the air molecules makes a single molecule's path unpredictable), but emergent theories let you throw away almost all the data and still retain an amazing amount of predictive power (e.g., the Earth's orbit needs only its center of mass, not every atom).124 - In Search Of Reality
- Conservation of information in quantum mechanics refers to the unitary evolution of the full wave function being reversible, so it does not contradict the fact that a Laplace's demon cannot in principle perfectly retrodict classical past states, because quantum uncertainty limits what can be extracted even though the underlying information is preserved.AMA | October 2024
- There is no infinite regress problem for the origin of the universe because the everyday principle that effects must be explained by prior causes does not apply to fundamental physics; the laws of physics are not cause-then-effect but a reversible pattern that, given a state at one moment, can be pushed forward or backward, so an eternal universe with no initial time simply always existed and requires no prior explanation.AMA | July 2022
- The future was not fixed at the Big Bang—chaos, nonlinearity, butterfly effects, and possibly quantum indeterminacy make the world genuinely unpredictable with multiple possible futures—but unpredictability provides no scope for free will, since being pushed around by random dice rolls confers no greater responsibility, and determinism is only visible retrospectively once one future has actualized.360 - We Really Don T Have Free Will
- There is a question of whether Laplace's Demon, with complete knowledge of physical state, would know the truth value of Goldbach's Conjecture—a mathematical rather than physical fact.AMA | Feb 2026
- Whether Laplace's Demon could know for certain what it will do next raises a self-reference problem: a system attempting to fully predict its own future state, including the act of prediction, may face logical limits, so even a perfect predictor of the external universe may not be able to certainly predict its own next action.AMA | March 2025