Lagrangian
A function summarizing a physical system's dynamics, from which equations of motion are derived, constrained by symmetries.
As defined in AMA | November 2025
Where it comes up · 14
- 334 | Daniel Whiteson on the Physics of and by Aliens2 claims
- Holiday Message | Hits and Misses2 claims
- Sean Carroll on the Biggest Ideas in the Universe | Closer To Truth Chats2 claims
- 158 | David Wallace on the Arrow of Time1 claim
- 268 | Matt Strassler on Relativity, Fields, and the Language of Reality1 claim
- 277 | Cumrun Vafa on the Universe According to String Theory1 claim
- AMA | April 20211 claim
- AMA | August 20211 claim
and 6 more
Most important claims · 10 of 17Search all claims for “Lagrangian” →
- Gravity can be described in several mutually incompatible-sounding but equivalent languages: as curvature of spacetime (not a force), as a force following the inverse square law, or as a manifestation of spin-2 particles in a condensate; all are correct and describe the same underlying phenomenon, just as Newtonian mechanics can be expressed via forces, Lagrangians, Hamiltonians, or Hamilton-Jacobi theory with identical predictions.268 | Matt Strassler on Relativity, Fields, and the Language of Reality
- Although black holes are completely characterized by mass, charge, and spin like fundamental particles (the 'no-hair' property), they are not sensibly regarded as fundamental particles or quanta of geometry, because they are macroscopic solutions of general relativity with internal entropy and many microstates, not single quantum excitations of a field with a Lagrangian.AMA | October 2025
- A Humean about laws of nature regards the world as a vast mosaic of local particular facts, but the continuous variation of fields described by a Lagrangian—where a field's value at a point is not independent of neighboring values—appears to impose a modal structure that Humeanism denies, raising the question of whether such continuity is itself just a regularity in the mosaic rather than a genuine constraint.AMA | June 2023
- Any modification of general relativity that does weird things with the curvature scalar (such as adding a 1/R term to the Lagrangian) generically brings a new dynamical degree of freedom to life; specifically, R + 1/R gravity is equivalent to a scalar-tensor theory with the metric plus a scalar field, and in such theories the ordinary Schwarzschild solution still holds, so no new effects appear far from gravitating objects.Holiday Message | Hits and Misses
- In real physics practice, one does not simply guess a Lagrangian and check until it works; Lagrangians are constrained by required symmetries and known behavior, so the 'just assume this Lagrangian' pedagogy compresses a disciplined process of writing down the most general form consistent with the symmetries and then fixing terms by experiment.AMA | November 2025
- The Lagrangian being kinetic minus potential energy (rather than the more intuitive total energy KE+PE) is not arbitrary: the principle of least action with L = KE - PE reproduces Newton's laws, and the minus sign reflects how the action functional must be structured so its stationary path yields the correct equations of motion, connecting to deeper principles like the path integral in quantum mechanics.AMA | March 2024
- Although all field configurations related by a gauge transformation are physically identical, gauging that symmetry locally requires introducing a gauge field that produces real, observable forces—an apparent paradox where a symmetry that keeps physics the same nonetheless generates something new.AMA | August 2023
- The principle of least action states that among all possible trajectories a system could take between two points in time, the actual trajectory is the one that minimizes (or more precisely, has a stationary value of) the action—a quantity computed by integrating the Lagrangian over time.Sean Carroll on the Biggest Ideas in the Universe | Closer To Truth Chats
- Most physicists are overconfident that aliens will share our physics: a string theorist told Whiteson he is sure aliens do string theory, and Whiteson estimates 95% of his department would expect that on contact 'we'll be at the board within 20 minutes talking about Lagrangians,' which David Tong's remark—'everything looks like quantum field theory because it's the only thing we can do'—reframes as a limitation rather than a discovery.334 | Daniel Whiteson on the Physics of and by Aliens
- The Lagrangian, Hamiltonian, and Newtonian formulations of classical mechanics are mathematically equivalent in their predictions, yet they are psychologically different because they employ different conceptual structures; this matters for extending physics beyond current understanding because different mathematical frameworks suggest different generalizations.Sean Carroll on the Biggest Ideas in the Universe | Closer To Truth Chats