LHC
The Large Hadron Collider, the world's highest-energy particle accelerator at CERN.
As defined in AMA | June 2024
Where it comes up · 11
- 289 | Cari Cesarotti on the Next Generation of Particle Experiments3 claims
- 321 | David Tong on Open Questions in Quantum Field Theory2 claims
- Dwarkesh Patel Podcast - Michael Nielsen – How science actually progresses1 claim
- 158 | David Wallace on the Arrow of Time1 claim
- 2 | Carlo Rovelli on Quantum Mechanics, Spacetime, and Reality1 claim
- 226 | Johanna Hoffman on Speculative Futures of Cities1 claim
- 370 | Daniel Akerib on a Faint Hint of Dark Matter1 claim
- AMA | July 20231 claim
and 3 more
Most important claims · 10 of 14Search all claims for “LHC” →
- The non-discovery of supersymmetric particles at the LHC, while not front-page news, was as important as the Higgs discovery; since string theory requires supersymmetry and many physicists strongly expected it to appear at LHC energies, its absence does not rule out string theory (supersymmetry could exist at higher energy) but should lower physicists' credence in string theory, just as a discovery would have raised it.2 | Carlo Rovelli on Quantum Mechanics, Spacetime, and Reality
- The naturalness argument (hierarchy problem) led most of the community, including Tong, to expect the LHC would find new particles accompanying the Higgs boson as a portal to the next layer of reality, but despite the LHC working beyond expectations and finding the Higgs, those particles are not there—so nature is telling us the well-motivated naturalness argument is wrong and the hierarchy problem has no solution.321 | David Tong on Open Questions in Quantum Field Theory
- The next generation of particle accelerators may not simply be a bigger proton collider like the LHC but could be a precision electron or muon collider, since each option probes different physics—proton machines for energy reach and discovery, lepton machines for clean precision measurements—and the choice reflects what physicists most want to probe next.AMA | June 2023
- Modern collective science like the LHC is so complex that no single person can understand everything in depth — finding the Higgs boson requires deep expertise in accelerator physics, inverse problems for particle-track simulation, quantum field theory, detector physics, vacuum physics, and data processing, each a lifetime of work — which is why thousand-author papers exist: people communicate at a high level but don't understand each other's specialties in depth.Dwarkesh Patel Podcast - Michael Nielsen – How science actually progresses
- Cumrun Vafa's apparent dismissal of supersymmetry as no longer an acceptable research area is notable; while the LHC has not found the lightest supersymmetric particle (LSP), it is questionable whether the entire theory has actually been ruled out by specific research.AMA | June 2024
- It is odd that a mathematical theorem could tell us spacetime cannot be discrete, because whether spacetime is fundamentally discrete should be a Planck-scale question requiring a collider 15 orders of magnitude more powerful than the LHC—information far above our experimental pay grade—so Tong does not believe the theorem's conclusion is right and thinks there must be a way to evade it by discarding one of its reasonable-seeming assumptions.321 | David Tong on Open Questions in Quantum Field Theory
- Collider design is constrained by mundane realities: a machine cannot be built bigger than the land you own (running into mountains, rivers, state borders, and property law), tunnels are extremely expensive so smaller is cheaper, and energy supply is a real limit—the LHC has run at reduced capacity due to Europe's energy shortage from the Russia-Ukraine war—so physicists must be responsible stewards of public money, space, and energy.289 | Cari Cesarotti on the Next Generation of Particle Experiments
- The high energy physics community of West's era was marked by intellectual narcissism and arrogance, believing it did the most fundamental and important science and was immune to human foibles like politics and emotion, an attitude exemplified by US physicists badmouthing the LHC while promoting the SSC and then praising the LHC once it discovered the Higgs.226 | Johanna Hoffman on Speculative Futures of Cities
- Physics uses infinity casually as a convenient approximation for large finite things (e.g., 'at infinity' in the LHC really means much bigger than the relevant scales), but when a genuine infinity appears — like the literally infinite future of a de Sitter universe — it is a substantial, deep posit beyond ordinary mathematical usage, and we may not actually know how to theorize about it, warranting caution.158 | David Wallace on the Arrow of Time
- Electron colliders collide fundamental point particles so the full collision energy is known and reconstructable, making them clean precision machines; proton colliders collide composite 'bags' of quarks and gluons (partons) sharing the proton's energy unpredictably, so no collision reaches the full beam energy but a wide variety of parton interactions makes them versatile discovery machines.289 | Cari Cesarotti on the Next Generation of Particle Experiments