Keynesian multiplier
The ratio measuring how much total economic output changes in response to a change in government spending; its size is disputed among economists.
As defined in Emanuel Derman on Theories, Models, and Science
Where it comes up · 8
- Mulligan on Redistribution, Unemployment, and the Labor Market3 claims
- John Papola on the Keynes Hayek Rap Videos 05/02/20112 claims
- Imports/Exports Data Reveal the Truth About the Global Economy1 claim
- Emanuel Derman on Theories, Models, and Science1 claim
- Robert Shiller on Narrative Economics1 claim
- Michael Faye and Paul Niehaus on GiveDirectly1 claim
- Russ Roberts (and Robin Hanson) on Truth and Economics 01/26/20091 claim
- Greg Mankiw on Gasoline Taxes, Keynes and Macroeconomics 1/22/20071 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “Keynesian multiplier” →
- The cash multiplier in Kenya differs from the domestic Keynesian multiplier because the money comes from outside the village rather than being taxed or printed locally; with US stimulus one must account for where the money came from, but in these studies the external injection means the village should clearly be better off, with the open question being whether nominal income rises more than the injection (true productivity gain) versus inflation offsetting it.Michael Faye and Paul Niehaus on GiveDirectly
- Economics is not a science not merely because its predictions are inaccurate, but because its predictions cannot be independently verified; when officials claim a stimulus created 3.3 million jobs, there is no independent way to check the claim other than the same model used to generate it—like claiming a rocket reached Mars solely because your model said it would, without being able to see or hear from the ship.Emanuel Derman on Theories, Models, and Science
- Economists who claim on television that putting money in the hands of the poor expands demand via the Keynesian multiplier have no research models supporting it, because all modern Keynesian models recognize that money must come from somebody who then spends less and that consumption is not the only activity; the only related research concerns wartime or defense buildups, from which they take an illegitimate leap to paying people not to produce anything.Mulligan on Redistribution, Unemployment, and the Labor Market
- Contrary to the Keynesian view that safety-net spending injects demand into the economy, transfers merely take money from one group and give it to another while reducing total work and income, so the net effect is less spending and a real reduction in economic activity.Mulligan on Redistribution, Unemployment, and the Labor Market
- The Keynesian multiplier is a great idea subject to two crucial caveats: it is only a short-run phenomenon, and when you take it to the data the estimated multipliers turn out not to be all that big, so even if Keynes was right in theory the practical multiplier effects may be small.Greg Mankiw on Gasoline Taxes, Keynes and Macroeconomics 1/22/2007
- The critical debt-to-GDP threshold is approximately 90%; above this point, the Keynesian multiplier inverts and each dollar borrowed and spent yields less than one dollar of GDP growth (compared to more than one dollar below 90%). The US debt-to-GDP ratio is currently ~125%, indicating severe constraints on fiscal stimulus effectiveness.Imports/Exports Data Reveal the Truth About the Global Economy
- The Director of the Congressional Budget Office justified applying a fiscal multiplier to unemployment insurance simply by saying 'that's Keynesian economics' and 'everyone else says it,' without any study of a country that expanded its UI and enjoyed a boom, because no such study exists.Mulligan on Redistribution, Unemployment, and the Labor Market
- A very large stimulus package (Krugman's proposed trillion dollars) is not supported by much empirical evidence, and Roberts's logical objection is that government spending must come from lenders or bond buyers, so it is deficit-financed and unlikely to raise total demand as Keynesians claim.Russ Roberts (and Robin Hanson) on Truth and Economics 01/26/2009
- The WWII evidence does not disprove Keynesianism in principle; even a Keynesian would admit that devoting all resources to fighting a war or digging and filling ditches yields desperate poverty rather than prosperity—the claim is only that WWII is not evidence FOR the Keynesian multiplier.John Papola on the Keynes Hayek Rap Videos 05/02/2011
- World War II did not stimulate the rest of the economy through a Keynesian multiplier; consumption outside the military sector shrank as scarce resources were diverted to making tanks, which is why there was rationing and a 'life of austerity'—so it is wrong to call wartime full employment prosperity.John Papola on the Keynes Hayek Rap Videos 05/02/2011