Jolly Roger
The skull-and-crossbones pirate flag, used as a signaling device to communicate that the attacker was an unconstrained outlaw pirate (who would brutalize resisters but spare those who surrendered), not a legally-restrained coast guard.
As defined in Peter Leeson on Pirates and the Invisible Hook 05/25/2009
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “Jolly Roger” →
- The Jolly Roger was an effective signal because flying it was cheap for pirates (already outlaws) but extremely costly for coast guard ships, which would step outside legal bounds and become subject to being hunted and hanged as pirates—so coast guards refrained from using it, preserving the flag's meaning.Peter Leeson on Pirates and the Invisible Hook 05/25/2009
- Pirates overcame the free-rider problem of the reputational benefit of mercy (which otherwise mainly helps the next crew) through captain- and crew-specific reputations and distinctive Jolly Roger designs, allowing them to internalize the benefit; Blackbeard's reputation was so effective that, per the leading historian, he apparently never actually killed anyone.Peter Leeson on Pirates and the Invisible Hook 05/25/2009
- The Jolly Roger functioned as a signaling device to communicate that an attacking ship was an unconstrained outlaw pirate rather than a legally-restricted coast guard vessel, which mattered because pirates—being outlaws—could brutally retaliate against resisting merchant ships while coast guards (and privateers) were legally restrained from doing so.Peter Leeson on Pirates and the Invisible Hook 05/25/2009
- Around 1721 the British government passed a law subjecting armed merchant crews to prison and wage forfeiture if they failed to defend against pirate attack, which is evidence both that merchant ships were overwhelmingly surrendering and that the pirates' Jolly Roger strategy was highly effective.Peter Leeson on Pirates and the Invisible Hook 05/25/2009