Honest signal
A signal that reliably conveys true information because it is costly or difficult to fake; here, tolerating teasing honestly reveals how much one values a relationship.
As defined in 346 | Erica Cartmill on How Human and Animal Minds Think and Play
Other definitions
A signal of quality that is reliable because faking it is too costly or mechanically impossible, so receivers can trust it.
Exploring the Frontier
Where it comes up · 3
- Exploring the Frontier2 claims
- Dave Hone1 claim
- 346 | Erica Cartmill on How Human and Animal Minds Think and Play1 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “Honest signal” →
- Sexually selected ornaments often function as honest signals or handicaps: black swans' curly wing feathers impair flight, and dark lion manes risk overheating, so bearing them while still thriving proves the individual's quality—explaining why predators evolved costly bright crests that also expose them to prey as a trade-off proving hunting prowess.Dave Hone
- Honest signals are reliable because they are too expensive or mechanically impossible to fake, so over evolutionary time signals in nature tend to retain a basis for honesty, though there is always some gamesmanship.Exploring the Frontier
- Playful teasing serves both to build and to test relationships by probing 'how far can I push you' and 'how far am I willing to be pushed'; what is acceptable is non-transferable across individuals (you can tease a close friend in ways you cannot tease your boss), and the willingness to tolerate teasing is an honest signal of how much one values the relationship over momentary annoyance—seen, for example, in how parents tolerate from children what they would not from strangers.346 | Erica Cartmill on How Human and Animal Minds Think and Play
- Honest prestige comes from skills or accomplishments that improve the lives of the group or community, while dishonest prestige comes from angling for TV exposure, manipulating one's image, or lying about achievements.Exploring the Frontier