What this covers
Dave Hone, a paleontologist, walks through how dinosaurs should be understood as real animals subject to the same biological and ecological constraints as living species, not as monsters constructed by speculation and cinema. The conversation centers on a single methodological claim: fossil evidence is always incomplete and distorted by the process of fossilization itself, so interpreting what it reveals requires scrupulous attention to taphonomy—the study of how bones move and change between death and discovery—before any conclusion about behavior or ecology can stand. Hone argues that popular culture and even peer-reviewed science routinely skip this step, favoring dramatic narratives over what the evidence actually supports. He demonstrates this problem across multiple domains: tyrannosaur hunting strategy, feather evolution, population-level behavior, and extinction mechanics.
The conversation ranges from specific fossil findings to broader principles of how to reason about incomplete data. On predation, Hone shows that predator-prey size ratio in living carnivores—typically 5–20% of the predator's mass—means T. rex hunted juvenile herbivores, not adult Triceratops as documentaries depict. On social behavior, he explains why the fact that Deinonychus may have hunted together tells us nothing about Velociraptor, since solitary and social species coexist even within single genera. He covers feather distribution across dinosaur groups, the biomechanics of dinosaur locomotion, how medullary bone identifies only laying females, and why over 90% of dinosaur species rest on single, often fragmentary specimens—a constraint that should humble any inference about growth, sexual dimorphism, or behavior. On extinction, he traces the K-Pg impact through ecosystem collapse rather than stopping at the asteroid itself, and explains why large terrestrial animals like dinosaurs were the worst-positioned to survive rapid climate change. He also addresses the legacy of Victorian assumptions about reptilian stupidity, and discusses whether pack hunting in dinosaurs is actually evidenced or merely suggested by proximity and film culture.
Hone argues that T. rex and dinosaurs were real animals governed by the same ecological and evolutionary rules as living species, and that careful interpretation of sparse, biased fossil evidence (taphonomy, bite marks, populations) can reconstruct their biology and behavior—while popular and even scientific narratives routinely overstate what the evidence supports.
- Carnivores predominantly hunt prey far smaller than themselves, and fossil bite marks and stomach contents confirm tyrannosaurs targeted juveniles, not adult equivalents.
- Fossils cannot be taken at face value; taphonomy determines whether evidence indicates predation, scavenging, or post-mortem transport.
- Population-level datasets (e.g., Protoceratops) are far more informative for behavior than single superlative specimens or new species.
Dinosaurs possessed sophisticated sensory systems and demonstrated intelligent, complex behaviors governed by modern ecological rules.
- Roughly 1,500-1,600 valid dinosaur species have been named, with about 40-50 new ones added each year for over a decade and no sign of slowing, as underexplored regions like India, Ecuador, Argentina, and Australia hold abundant unexcavated material.
“we’ve named, give or take, in the realm of 1,500, 1,600 valid species... we also name in the realm of 40 to 50 a year”
- Evolution's apparent improbabilities are resolved by scale: populations of millions over millions of years producing thousands of offspring each yield astronomical numbers of trials, so even rare beneficial mutations appear—'rolling dice but getting to keep the sixes'—as illustrated by the ocean sunfish releasing up to 300 million eggs at once.
“a friend of mine said, 'No, it’s rolling dice but it gets to keep the sixes.'”
- Because dinosaurs grew and matured over long windows, a big female can look like a small male, making sexing extremely difficult; Hone's gharial study (~110 specimens) showed that apart from the very biggest males, sexes are nearly indistinguishable, mirroring modeling for alligators and implying dinosaur dimorphism could be strong yet undetectable.
“you run into the problem that a big female will look like a small male. And we can’t sex them.”
- Dinosaurs followed the same ecological guidelines as modern animals, including the island rule, so isolated populations evolved into weird forms—as seen in the dwarfed and unusual dinosaurs of the Cretaceous Hateg island chain—but the weirdest lineages, like volcanic-island faunas, rarely fossilize and are largely lost to us.
“You get dinosaurs on islands, they turn weird. We see that.”
- After a period of arguing giraffe necks were sexually selected for combat, renewed study of short-necked relatives like the okapi and other lines of evidence confirmed the original view that long necks are primarily about feeding—illustrating how examining ancestral and miniaturized forms resolves functional debates.
“ultimately, it came out that we were right the first time. This is all about feeding.”
- Protoceratops is arguably the only dinosaur for which a true population can be studied—over 100 good skeletons from embryos to adults, from one place in Mongolia within a ~100,000-year window—making it uniquely valuable for studying growth, sexual selection, dimorphism, and population structure, more so than describing new species.
“you’ve got one population from one place, from one time with 100 animals from embryos up to big adults.”
- Claims that T. rex had primate-level intelligence (based on neuron-density estimates of ~3 billion) were rebutted by a team revising neuron counts down to roughly 250 million to 1.7 billion, similar to crocodiles, which fits expectations given that T. rex's brain is a small fraction of a chimp's despite weighing seven tons.
“that was shot down within a few months by a team of paleontologists and a couple of other neurologists who really went to town on it.”
- The dinosaurs were killed by an asteroid impact off the Yucatan ~66 million years ago that hit the worst possible rock, throwing up an ash cloud causing a near-instant nuclear winter; the lasting damage came from rapid climate change triggering ecosystem collapse through cascading interdependencies, with all five mass extinctions ultimately being too-rapid climate change.
“There are five recognized mass extinctions in the history of life on Earth, and all of them are ultimately some form of climate change... it’s climate changing too quickly for things to adapt to.”
- Medullary bone—a blood-vessel-rich calcium store grown in large bones during egg-laying—can be detected in thin-sectioned dinosaur bone to identify a female, but only one that was laying eggs at death; males, juveniles, and non-breeding or post-laying females lack it, so it identifies laying females rather than distinguishing all males from all females.
“we can tell laying female from everything else.”
- It would be surprising if no dinosaurs survived the K-Pg extinction in isolated refugia (an island or valley like Hawaii or New Zealand) for hundreds of thousands to millions of years, given that mammals, crocodiles, birds, newts, and frogs survived; but such places rarely form fossils, so we will almost certainly never find evidence.
“I’d be amazed if there wasn’t some equivalent of Hawaii or New Zealand or some other tucked away island or valley where actually dinosaurs were fine for anything from a few hundred thousand to a couple of million years.”
- CT scanning the bony inner ear of dinosaurs lets paleontologists infer the frequency range of sounds the ear was structured to detect, and endocasts of the brain case reveal the relative sizes of olfactory and optic regions, indicating how much of the brain was devoted to smell and sight.
“We can CT scan into the structure of the bony inner ear, and from that you can actually get an idea of what frequency of sounds the inner ear was structured to be pitched to.”
- Absolute eye size, not proportional size, determines visual capability, and eyeball size correlates with visual acuity across mammals and birds; T. rex's tennis-ball-sized eyes imply either excellent long-range daytime vision or excellent low-light vision, with Hone suspecting nocturnality at large size.
“really important for vision is absolute size, not proportional size.”
- Birds are dinosaurs in the same way humans are apes: tracing all 10,000-plus bird species back to their common ancestor leads to a dinosaur very close to a small Velociraptor-like form, so birds descended from and therefore are dinosaurs—and they coexisted with non-avian dinosaurs for ~100 million years rather than arising after them.
“birds have literally descended from dinosaurs, therefore they are dinosaurs. We have literally descended from other apes, we are apes.”
- The assumption that dinosaurs were dumb stems from Victorian-era speciesism and a hierarchy placing mammals above reptiles, but this is unfounded—some birds (crows, parrots) are as intelligent as apes, so some dinosaurs were highly intelligent, and the senility/egg-eating extinction hypotheses are baseless given dinosaurs coexisted with mammals for 100 million years.
“that comes down to A) That bit of kind of classic almost Victorian speciesism”
- Feathers massively predate bird origins, appearing in Middle Jurassic tyrannosaurs ~165 million years ago and across roughly eight or nine major dinosaur groups; they likely evolved bifunctionally for insulation in warm-blooded dinosaurs and for sexual/communication display, offering advantages scales cannot provide such as shedding, color change, and erection.
“Feathers do stuff that scales can’t. You can shed them in winter and change color and come back as another one.”
Taphonomic evidence must precede behavioral interpretation; bone associations and trackways cannot reliably distinguish hunting from coexistence.
- By determining whether bite marks sit on top of erosion damage, paleontologists can establish that feeding was scavenging on a long-dead, weathered carcass rather than active predation—as in a Mongolian hadrosaur whose bites overlay erosion, proving it had been dead for days or weeks before being chewed.
“we’re pretty confident that the bite marks are sitting on top of erosion... that thing has been dead and sitting out for days, possibly weeks, before something came along and chewed on it.”
- You cannot interpret fossils at face value—especially for behavior and ecology—because much can happen between an animal's death and its discovery (transport by water, erosion, scavenging), so taphonomy must be used to reconstruct the true sequence of events before drawing conclusions.
“you basically can’t take fossils at face value, particularly when you’re trying to get into stuff like behavior and ecology because between the animal dying and the paleontologist digging it up, potentially quite a lot has happened”
- Diagramming where bones are found matters because long bones align with currents, so a row of aligned bones indicates significant water transport and predicts that small light bones are missing or relocated downhill—information critical to deciding whether an animal died in place and how to interpret the assemblage.
“if you’re finding all the bones are in a line, that probably tells you that this thing has had quite a lot of water washing over it.”
- When multiple truly independent lines of evidence converge on the same answer, the conclusion becomes powerful—as with spinosaurs, where conical teeth, crocodile-like skulls, aquatic-system occurrence, isotopic signatures matching fish-eaters, and fish scales in Baryonyx's chest all point to a fish-linked, water-associated lifestyle.
“Can you get stuff that is as far as possible truly independent from the other data and does it give you the same answer?... that’s incredibly powerful.”
- Group versus solitary behavior cannot be inferred from close relatives, since lions are social but other big cats are not, spotted hyenas are social yet brown and striped hyenas are solitary, and some canids hunt in packs while maned wolves are solitary; therefore Deinonychus group hunting (if real) tells us nothing about Velociraptor.
“you just can’t do group versus solitary off close relatives or anything like that.”
- Despite Jurassic Park's depiction, the evidence for pack hunting in any dinosaur is almost nonexistent; associations like Deinonychus with Tenontosaurus or tyrannosaur trackways at best show animals may have lived or moved together, not that they hunted cooperatively, since even solitary modern animals leave grouped trackways and predator traps can pile up carcasses.
“The evidence for pack hunting in any dinosaur at all is almost nonexistent. It basically doesn’t exist.”
- A gold-standard demonstration of group hunting would be trackways where multiple carnivores' footprints alternately overprint each other while converging on a herbivore, proving they were present simultaneously rather than minutes or hours apart—evidence Hone considers theoretically findable but not yet found.
“if you trace the footprints of the individual carnivores, and if A’s early on, A’s footprint goes on top of B’s, but later on B’s go on top of A’s, they must have been there at the same time”
Paleontological inference about dinosaur behavior and population dynamics is fundamentally constrained by fragmentary, vanishing evidence and limited sample size.
- Over 90% of dinosaur species are known from a single, often incomplete specimen, and fewer than ten species have enough complete skeletons to compare populations, which fundamentally limits behavioral, sexual-dimorphism, and growth inferences.
“The vast majority of dinosaur species, like 90 plus percent, are known from a single specimen”
- Complete skeletons almost never lie exposed on the surface because lithified, porous bones shatter from sandstorm etching and freeze-thaw cracking; finds typically begin as a tiny sliver of bone protruding from a hillside, behind which a near-complete skeleton may remain buried, as with Linheraptor found from a few millimeters of exposed claw.
“What you rarely find is a decent bone on the surface, let alone a skeleton.”
- Paleontology is fundamentally different from other sciences because fossils sit in eroding rocks and disappear if not collected, so the science is literally vanishing—unlike physics or genetics which can be studied anytime—making excavation urgent even though Hone presents the 'fund only paleontology' idea as a joke.
“fossils are in places that erode, and if we don’t dig them up, they’re gone... we’re in a fundamentally different field where our science is literally disappearing.”
- Technologies like MRI and seismic surveys mostly fail to detect buried fossils because bones take on the mineral density of the surrounding rock, and these methods detect density differences—so when bone and matrix densities match, the fossil is effectively invisible.
“the bones take on some of the properties of the minerals in which they’re embedded, which means their density is really similar. And things like MRIs or seismic activity is basically looking for differences in density.”
T. rex combined powerful bite force with selective muscle-tissue scraping and primarily hunted juvenile rather than adult prey.
- T. rex killed and dismembered prey with its large lateral teeth but fed selectively using its small, flat-backed incisiform front teeth to scrape meat from muscle-rich areas like the deltopectoral crest, leaving distinctive close parallel scratch marks—analogous to scraping cream from an Oreo.
“it kills and dismembers with the big teeth up the side- … and then it feeds with the little front teeth.”
- Compared to similarly sized carnivores like Giganotosaurus, T. rex has dramatically more bone in its skull with much smaller fenestrae and a thicker jaw, evolved to resist the forces of its uber-powerful bite, with fused nasals making the snout rigid—an adaptation present even in early small tyrannosaurs.
“their heads are the same size, and as animals, they are about the same linear dimensions. But you can just see, there’s just way more bone in the T-Rex.”
- T. rex engaged in cannibalism, evidenced by a tyrannosaur foot bone bearing T. rex feeding scrape traces (and a jaw with an embedded T. rex tooth); the multiple unhealed feeding-type marks indicate consumption rather than fighting, and because T. rex was the only large carnivore around, big bites on big bones must be T. rex.
“there’s a T-Rex foot bone with these distinctive feeding traces on them.”
- Juveniles are the universal predation target because they are small, weak, lack defenses like horns or armor, are naive about predators, forage inefficiently, and get chased into suboptimal habitats by adults—a rule of thumb operating from fish to big cats and almost certainly for dinosaurs.
“This is just a universal pattern of being a smaller animal versus a larger, or a younger animal versus a larger animal.”
- The vast majority of active predation, including by tyrannosaurs, targets prey much smaller than the predator (roughly 5-20% of its mass), so T. rex primarily ate juveniles of large herbivores rather than adult equivalents, contrary to documentary depictions of T. rex hunting adult Triceratops.
“The vast majority of active predation is on stuff much, much, much smaller than you.”
- T. rex was about 12 meters long, four to five meters tall, and around seven metric tons—described by Tom Holtz as an orca on land—making it a colossal biped far heavier than a large African elephant.
“a colleague of mine, Tom Holtz, described them as an orca on land”
Sexual and social selection drove ornament evolution, signaling mate quality and dominance through costly, honest traits.
- The crests, horns, and head ornaments of carnivorous dinosaurs likely evolved through socio-sexual selection—covering both mate attraction and social dominance—because they lack obvious mechanical function and appear across most non-feathered carnivorous dinosaurs, paralleling features like lion manes that are simultaneously attractive and intimidating.
“I’ve always favored the term socio-sexual selection to cover both sexual display and sexual dominance and communication, but also social ones, because those two things are hard to tell apart.”
- Sexually selected ornaments often function as honest signals or handicaps: black swans' curly wing feathers impair flight, and dark lion manes risk overheating, so bearing them while still thriving proves the individual's quality—explaining why predators evolved costly bright crests that also expose them to prey as a trade-off proving hunting prowess.
“It’s what’s called an honest signal. You couldn’t have those curly feathers if you weren’t able to support them.”
- When both sexes bear ornaments (mutual sexual selection, as in black swans, starlings, penguins), it suggests both invest in rearing offspring and mate-choose each other, so the presence of crests in both sexes of Triceratops and tyrannosaurs hints they may have cooperated in reproduction—though this signal is compromised by tiny dinosaur sample sizes.
“when you’ve got signals in both males and females like every triceratops or every tyrannosaurus, it at least hints that they’re going down this route and that they might cooperate for reproduction.”
Dinosaur biomechanics—locomotion, jaw mechanics, skeletal design—reflect efficient engineering comparable to modern vertebrates.
- Dinosaurs walked by pulling the leg back using a massive muscle block on the first third to half of the tail anchored to the femur—like lizards and crocodiles—whereas mammals use the butt; the long tail muscle (2.5-3m in T. rex) allows greater contraction and is a fundamentally efficient design.
“They have this giant set of muscles on the first half of the tail that’s anchoring on the femur, so the thigh bone, on the back of that, and muscles contract.”
- In a realistic encounter, Spinosaurus would lose to T. rex despite being longer, because its long thin jaw is comparatively weak and its neck is strong vertically but very weak rotating side-to-side, whereas T. rex has the strongest neck and bite—pitting the weakest jaw and spin against the strongest neck.
“you’ve got the weakest jaw with the weakest spin versus the strongest neck. So no, I don’t buy it.”
- Tyrannosaurs (and several independently evolving theropod groups) evolved a middle metatarsal that pinches into a flattened diamond shape, locking the foot bones together so they can't splay under load; this preserves elastic energy return from soft tissues, making walking more energy efficient.
“if you lock the feet together, the bones can’t move and instead, that’s going to further compress those soft tissue bits and give you a bit more spring.”
Predator ecology, extinction mechanics, and dinosaur cultural legacy reveal broader patterns independent of specimen completeness.
- Dinosaur and fossil finds were probably not the inspiration for dragon myths, since dragons appear in cultures like Britain with almost no dinosaurs, and if shared faunas (e.g., similar East Asian and North American dinosaur groups) had inspired them, different cultures would produce similar mythical creatures rather than the very different dragons they actually have.
“If they were all seeing the same skeleton, they’d probably all produce the same kind of mythical animals. They all produce... Different ones.”
- T. rex is not just an iconic predator but one of the most recognized animals, period, ranking alongside lions, elephants, and giraffes in public familiarity.
“I think it’s one of the most iconic animals, period.”
- There is basically nothing in science fiction that doesn't already exist on Earth in some form, because the diversity of real organisms—velvet worms, caecilians and their reproductive behaviors—is so vast and bizarre that most invented creatures have real analogs.
“There is basically nothing in science fiction that doesn’t already exist on Earth in some way, shape or form.”
- Carnivores generally avoid eating other carnivores—especially their own species—because conspecifics that eat identical food carry the same parasites and are thus the most likely to transmit infection, making habitual cannibalism rare unless an animal is starving or has just won a fight.
“What’s the one thing that’s definitely going to have the most parasites in it that can infect you as, for example, a lion? It’s another lion that eats the exact same stuff that you do.”
- High-end dinosaur fossils are priced like art—worth whatever people will pay—so Stan the T. rex selling for $31.8 million and Apex the Stegosaurus exceeding it reflect a massive T. rex brand premium and buyer demand rather than scientific or completeness value, since a far more complete Stegosaurus (Sophie) sold for only ~£250,000.
“it’s a bit like the art market, in that it’s worth what people will pay for it.”
- Predator traps like the La Brea Tar Pits accumulate disproportionate numbers of carnivores because a single struggling herbivore lures successive predators in to die, producing distorted ratios such as roughly 100 dire wolves and 40 Smilodon for only a few herbivores; algal-toxin ponds create similar pileups without physical entrapment.
“it’s just sucking the carnivores in. And you get these really distorted ratios.”
- Ecologically, an apex predator is defined as one that eats other predators (like a great white eating tuna and sea lions); lions and T. rex eat herbivores, so they are better termed 'arch predators'—the largest predator in their ecosystem—rather than apex predators, a distinction commonly misused.
“apex predators are generally defined as things that eat other predators... Whereas people love saying lions are apex predators... They’re eating herbivores.”
- In climate-driven extinctions, terrestrial animals fare worse than aquatic ones because water is a great equilibrating medium allowing escape to better conditions, while land animals are trapped by deserts, mountains, and rivers; dinosaurs being mostly big and terrestrial were the worst possible combination.
“terrestrial things generally do worse than things in water because water’s a great equilibrating medium”
- A fully healed major fracture in a skeleton can evidence the existence of society, since survival through months of healing implies a group devoted enough to care for the injured individual—and by analogy, the human fossil record would reveal medicine and technology through healed compound fractures and treated bone cancers.
“if that person was on their own, just dead, someone had to look after them for months to get that level of healing... so that’s your society.”
- Human evolution was likely improbable without the dinosaur extinction because dinosaurs dominated ecological niches for ~140 million years; even after their extinction, mammals competed with large birds like phorusrhacids, so there was no guarantee mammals—let alone primates—would have risen.
“if you saw an animal bigger than a raccoon, it was probably a dinosaur. That’s how incredibly dominant they...”
- Evolution is descent with modification—editing an existing body plan rather than inventing from scratch or perfecting—which is why tetrapods share the one-bone-two-bones-blocky-bones limb pattern and retain bodge-job compromises like the vertebrate eye's blind spot, and why interlinked traits constrain change.
“It’s Darwin’s line: 'It’s descent with modification.'... You’re making edits to the existing plan, which is why you don’t have animals with tentacles.”
Evolutionary processes including runaway selection, functional repurposing, and size trends shaped dinosaur lineages under real ecological constraints.
- Evolution repurposes structures to new functions: the swim bladder, evolved for buoyancy and minimal oxygen processing, enabled fish like Tiktaalik to exploit land, and elephant tusks likely began as sexually selected display features before being co-opted for digging, fighting, and bark-stripping—so traits should be analyzed for both their possible functions and their original selective driver.
“It develops it for one function, but once you get there, you’re like, 'Oh, okay, this could be used for another function,'”
- The sexy-sons hypothesis holds that females may prefer a trait simply because it is different, and since difference implies variation that confers resistance to parasites and changing environments, preference for novelty can become self-reinforcing—daughters inherit the preference and sons the trait—driving runaway ornamentation closer to pure beauty, as seen in swordtail-molly mate-choice experiments.
“There’s more red and the females like more red, and you don’t have to come back much further and suddenly all the males are bright red.”
- Cope's Rule describes the tendency for lineages to get bigger over time, driven by diffusion (you can't get much smaller) and real advantages—better hunting, energy efficiency, dominance in contests—but big animals fare worst in extinction events because they need more resources, have smaller populations, less genetic diversity, and slow reproduction, which resets the size clock.
“they’re less likely to survive because they need more fuel. What would feed a mouse for a year won’t feed an elephant for a week.”
T. rex occupied an ecologically extreme niche as the sole apex predator with no comparably sized competitors.
- T. rex is unusual even among giant tyrannosaurs because it is by far the largest carnivore in its ecosystem, with no comparably sized predatory competitors—an extreme size gap analogous to lions being the apex while the next biggest predator is weasel-sized, which is not normal in ecosystems.
“T. rex is definitely weird, even compared to all the other giant tyrannosaurs that are very closely related to it, because it is by far, ludicrously by far, the largest carnivore in its ecosystem.”
- T. rex moved at perhaps 25 mph at the upper estimate and never ran in the biomechanical sense (both feet off the ground); it was a power walker whose four-to-five-meter stride covered ground efficiently, with one foot always on the ground for loading due to its mass.
“T-rex, is going to be a power walker. It’s not going to run in the conventional biomechanical sense where both feet are off the ground at once.”
- Larger animals are disproportionately vulnerable in extinction events because they need more fuel and territory, have smaller populations and thus less genetic diversity for selection to act on, and reproduce slowly, all of which leave evolution little to work with compared to abundant fast-breeding small animals.
“they’re less likely to survive because they need more fuel. What would feed a mouse for a year won’t feed an elephant for a week.”
Popular dinosaur depictions in films contradict research on vision, running, pack behavior, and anatomy without extra effort or cost.
- Spinosaurus was probably a giant wading predator akin to a weird stork rather than a good swimmer or diver; Hone and colleagues' analyses savaged the swimming hypothesis, and several original proponents have reversed their position, with the long thin sail-backed body and weak rotational neck strength arguing against aquatic agility.
“I think it’s basically a big wader. It’s a poor analogy, but it’s a very weird, giant stork.”
- The Jurassic Park premise that T. rex cannot see you if you don't move is fiction with no basis in research; T. rex had giant tennis-ball-sized eyes and excellent vision, and Crichton apparently invented the claim, attributing it to a nonexistent paper.
“it’s nonsense. They can see really well. Like I said, T-rex has giant eyeballs.”
- Making creature designs scientifically accurate in films is no more effort than making them inaccurate, since designers constantly tweak models anyway, so the choice to be inaccurate (e.g., adding teeth to the beaked Gallimimus or worsening Jurassic World pterosaurs versus JP3) is unjustified given accuracy could deepen engagement at no extra cost.
“he said, 'It’s no harder to make it accurate than to make it inaccurate.' And it’s like, if that’s truly the case, then just make it right.”