Holdup problem
A situation where one party with a necessary piece can extract excessive value by threatening to withhold it after others have committed resources.
As defined in Michael Heller on Gridlock and the Tragedy of the Anticommons 11/02/2009
Other definitions
A situation where one party, after another has made an investment, can extract value or block progress by exploiting its bargaining position—e.g., bureaucrats withholding licenses or utilities.
Stephen Jennings
Where it comes up · 2
- Michael Heller on Gridlock and the Tragedy of the Anticommons 11/02/20093 claims
- Stephen Jennings2 claims
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “Holdup problem” →
- Government creates holdup problems at every level—bureaucrats withholding water, licenses, or creating tax issues—and there are economies of scale in mitigating those problems once on behalf of all residents and developers, rather than each of thousands of actors solving the holdup problem individually.Stephen Jennings
- The more Rendeavour solves holdup problems and raises the value of the land and community, the more it creates one large concentrated holdup risk—the incentive for politics to confiscate the rents from the land rises and the project becomes a juicier target; the counterbalance is to continuously add jobs and benefits so the project is recognized as providing huge value to the wider community.Stephen Jennings
- Cutting-edge medical treatments like gene therapy and cancer diagnostics require access to many separately patented genes, each owned by a small biotech startup that demands a price reflecting potential profits from the whole therapy, creating a holdup problem where assembling all the patents becomes prohibitively costly.Michael Heller on Gridlock and the Tragedy of the Anticommons 11/02/2009
- Eminent domain solves the holdup problem by eliminating individual ownership when assembling a large bundle of property rights, but it is a last-best 'nuclear option'—abused (raising Public Choice problems, as in Kelo), broadly hated, and not the right approach for intellectual property, where the analogous government 'march-in' right on patents would crush pharmaceutical companies' incentive to invest the ~billion dollars it takes to develop a drug.Michael Heller on Gridlock and the Tragedy of the Anticommons 11/02/2009
- There are many private, quiet ways to solve gridlock/holdup—such as assembling land without a big announcement and buying parcels quietly—and there have been many successful examples.Michael Heller on Gridlock and the Tragedy of the Anticommons 11/02/2009