H-1B
A US temporary work visa category for high-skilled foreign workers, subject to annual caps.
As defined in Michael Clemens on Aid, Migration, and Poverty
Where it comes up · 4
- Marc Andreessen2 claims
- Dan Wang1 claim
- Leopold Aschenbrenner — 2027 AGI, China/US super-intelligence race, & the return of history1 claim
- Michael Clemens on Aid, Migration, and Poverty1 claim
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “H-1B” →
- Proposed work-visa schemes (the low-skill W-Visa and high-skill H-1B) impose both numerical caps and a labor-market test requiring employers to prove no American would take the job; this combination is incoherent—once an employer proves no American is available, capping the visa (e.g., the 200,001st) helps no native worker, hurts the employer and economy, and deprives a migrant of tripling or quadrupling their living standard, so removing such provisions is Pareto-improving.Michael Clemens on Aid, Migration, and Poverty
- Silicon Valley startups mostly use the O-1 'super genius' visa for breakthrough founders rather than the H-1B, because the H-1B program has been captured by a small set of big tech volume hirers and 'consulting mills' (e.g., Cognizant) that bring in thousands of mid-tier IT workers at $60-100k wages, leaving little tech effectively unable to use the rigged system.Marc Andreessen
- The dysfunctional US immigration system nearly forced Dwarkesh into a default 'code monkey' path: as a dependent on his doctor father's H-1B, he faced being kicked off the decades-long Indian green card queue at 21 and restarting, unable to do a startup; only because COVID fast-tracked the backlog (fewer incoming foreigners) did he get a green card months before turning 21, which contingently enabled him to pursue the podcast—illustrating the large cultural and human-capital impact of immigration policy.Leopold Aschenbrenner — 2027 AGI, China/US super-intelligence race, & the return of history
- The standard Silicon Valley argument for high-skilled immigration (H-1B/O-1) is that importing the world's smartest people increases US company productivity, and those immigrants then create new companies, technologies, and industries that generate far more jobs for native-born Americans — a positive-sum flywheel where everyone wins.Marc Andreessen
- Chinese people are extremely responsive to incentives and intensely pragmatic: rather than being aggrieved by an obstacle they navigate around it, which explains both why ordinary Chinese adapt smoothly to shocks like H-1B visa changes and why officials generated enormous GDP growth when bureaucratic incentives rewarded maximizing growth and minimizing 'mass incidents' (protests).Dan Wang