normative

Visa caps with labor-market tests harm everyone

Proposed work-visa schemes (the low-skill W-Visa and high-skill H-1B) impose both numerical caps and a labor-market test requiring employers to prove no American would take the job; this combination is incoherent—once an employer proves no American is available, capping the visa (e.g., the 200,001st) helps no native worker, hurts the employer and economy, and deprives a migrant of tripling or quadrupling their living standard, so removing such provisions is Pareto-improving.

normativepending

Speaker

Michael Clemens

Evidence Quote

“Everybody loses in that scenario. So if more open borders means getting rid of provisions of legislation that don't help anyone and hurt everyone, then movements toward open borders fall into that class of things that economists love to search for--which are Pareto-optimal things.”

Source

Michael Clemens on Aid, Migration, and Poverty— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:10:08 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...