Gesamtkunstwerk
A 'total work of art' fusing music, drama, poetry, staging, and design into a unified whole—the Wagnerian ideal in which excerpting loses the dramatic meaning of the whole.
As defined in Alex Ross
Where it comes up · 3
- Dana Gioia2 claims
- Alex Ross1 claim
- Bryan Caplan1 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “Gesamtkunstwerk” →
- The scarcest skill in writing opera librettos is taking it seriously: a libretto must work as a poem, be loose enough that the composer can set it to music yet tight enough to have form, and be inhabitable so the singer can become the words for the performance—creating beautiful language a singer can inhabit like a great pop song.Dana Gioia
- Wagner was ambivalent about excerpting his works: extracting pieces like the 'Ride of the Valkyries' was brilliant marketing that spread his fame, but pulling out a passage such as the entry of the gods into Valhalla strips it of dramatic irony—what sounds grandiose and uplifting is actually an empty, hollow spectacle masking a catastrophe—so Wagner is richest experienced whole as theater.Alex Ross
- Opera is a Gesamtkunstwerk (combined artwork) of stagecraft, poetry, music, and acting, and if any one element fails the whole fails—just as a singer with a bad voice ruins an opera—so great lyrics are what make musical theater and opera either excellent or lousy.Dana Gioia
- Caplan's aesthetic heuristic for serious art is to seek out whatever a group of fanatical, devoted people considers the best thing in the world — especially works by megalomaniacal creators (like Wagner's Gesamtkunstwerk) who treat their work as a total reflection of themselves — because such intensely loved works usually reward a lifetime of attention, in contrast to half-watched sitcoms that waste one's aesthetic life.Bryan Caplan