What this covers
Dana Gioia, poet and former chairman of the National Endowment for the Arts, discusses how the arts function in human life and culture. He traces a historical rupture: mid-20th-century intellectuals stripped poetry of rhyme, meter, narrative, and accessibility, reserving it for an elite audience. The common people, rather than abandon poetry, rebuilt it from the ground up—Kool Herc inventing hip hop in the South Bronx, alongside slam poetry, cowboy poetry, and the new formalism movement. Gioia argues that this reinvention mirrors oral poetry traditions as ancient as Homer. He connects this cultural fracture to concrete harms: the loss of rich narratives leaves people without the stories they need to navigate crisis and reshape their lives, contributing to epidemics of suicide and opioid addiction.
The conversation ranges across philosophy, aesthetics, and institutional history. Gioia applies Lukács's analysis to literary studies, showing how the field became self-referential and lost its connection to why literature matters. He examines opera and the libretto—arguing that poets like W. H. Auden learned that great dramatic verse must leave room for the composer, not dominate it. On museums, he challenges the modern assumption that they should drive cultural change; they are instead conservation technologies, meant to preserve and make accessible the achievements of the past. He advocates for mastering the craft of writing across forms, draws on Catholic theology to explain how metaphor works, and traces the cultural power of shared myths—how Virgil and Augustus unified an empire not through argument but through story and image. Throughout, he contends that intellectual depth comes from sustained engagement with enduring works, not from chasing novelty.
Gioia argues that poetry and the arts serve an essential human function—enlarging empathy and giving people the narratives needed to live—and that intellectual elites severed poetry from common people, who then reinvented it from the ground up (rap, slam, cowboy poetry); the path to cultural and personal richness lies in conserving the deep past rather than chasing novelty.
- Intellectuals removed rhyme, meter, and narrative from poetry, so common people reinvented oral poetry as rap and hip hop
- The deprivation and cheapening of narrative carries real human cost, contributing to the suicide and opioid epidemics
- Art's purpose is conservation—building on the past—and immersion in durable works beats the ephemeral commercial culture
Deep craft, lived experience, and emotional resonance matter more than fashionable or abstract conceits.
- The function of a church is misunderstood by modern architects: a cathedral's purpose is to bring you into a space where spiritual contemplation, experience, and transformation become possible that would not happen outside—Chartres and Mont St. Michel convert visitors—whereas modernist functionality (comfortable seating and lighting) makes a church indistinguishable from an Elks lodge.
“the function of a church is different than what architects think... A purpose of a cathedral is to bring you into a space in which spiritual contemplation and experience is possible.”
- When reviewing books of poetry, the right method is to ask three questions: what is the writer trying to do, how well does the writer do it, and—most importantly—how worthwhile was the thing they wanted to do; sometimes people do marvelous jobs of things not worth the effort.
“What is the writer doing? What’s the writer trying to do? Secondly, how well does the writer do this? Then, there’s the third question... How worthwhile was the thing that they wanted to do and they did?”
- Being in the university made Gioia too self-conscious as a poet, leading him to write poems to be interpreted rather than to be experienced; he realized that figures like Wallace Stevens and T.S. Eliot were never in the university and that he could make a living as a writer another way.
“I just felt that being in the university was making me, as a poet, too self-conscious. I was writing poems to be interpreted, rather than to be experienced.”
- Learning every character in a great epic poem, though hard, demonstrates that every moment in a great work of art contributes to the total effect—none of these things are accidental, everything has meaning.
“what it does do is show you that every moment in a great work of art contributes to the total effect. That none of these things are accidental, everything has meaning.”
- The scarcest skill in writing opera librettos is taking it seriously: a libretto must work as a poem, be loose enough that the composer can set it to music yet tight enough to have form, and be inhabitable so the singer can become the words for the performance—creating beautiful language a singer can inhabit like a great pop song.
“it has to work as a poem, it has to work as something that the composer can set to music, which means it has to be tight enough to have a form but not so tight that the composer can’t get into it.”
- Auden, like the 18th-century poets, modeled refusing hyper-specialization—writing lyrics, ballads, verse epistles, satires, plays, and song lyrics—whereas most poets today write only one-page typographic lyrics in a single found voice; a poet should instead stay open to any genre, style, and form throughout a career.
“You see this assumption right now that a poet finds a voice, a style and they just keep working in that same vein their whole career. Where I think that you should be open to any possibility of genre, of style, of form.”
- The modern movement (roughly 1914 to WWII) made all the arts more abstract and conceptual and biased against narrative, treating storytelling as condescending to a stupid audience; but humanity needs stories, because people live their lives as stories and need a wealth of narrative possibilities to revise their own life-narratives when they reach an impasse.
“there was a general bias against narrative. Putting a story in was somehow condescending to a stupid audience but the fact is, humanity needs stories.”
- Auden's claim that opera is the last refuge of the high style in poetry is true with a vengeance: filmmakers no longer call poets to rewrite screenplays, but opera still needs the poet because it needs language and stories that are elevated, concise, and lyrical.
“in opera, they still need the poet because they need language in stories that are elevated, concise, and lyrical.”
- Opera is a Gesamtkunstwerk (combined artwork) of stagecraft, poetry, music, and acting, and if any one element fails the whole fails—just as a singer with a bad voice ruins an opera—so great lyrics are what make musical theater and opera either excellent or lousy.
“If you have one element of that combination that doesn’t work, the whole doesn’t work. In the same way that if you have a singer with a bad voice, opera doesn’t work.”
- Auden's best-written libretto, Paul Bunyan, made a terrible opera precisely because it was so well written that nothing could be done with it; as Auden progressed his libretti became less poetically distinguished but more dramatically powerful—a libretto must leave room for the composer.
“His greatest libretto in terms of poetry is his first one called Paul Bunyan, which made an absolutely terrible opera because it was so well written, you couldn’t do anything with it.”
Art must serve all communities rather than remain confined to academic or elite institutional gatekeepers.
- There is little good American poetry about business because people write from their (mostly academic) life experience, and because business and money are the only two obscene topics left in American poetry—you can write about sexual acts or excrement and be praised, but writing about business marks you as polluted, so even business-experienced poets avoid it to escape peer criticism.
“business and money are the only two obscene topics left in American poetry. You can write specifically about sexual acts or excrement in American poetry and be praised, but if you write about business, you’re considered somehow polluted.”
- In leading the NEA, treating every member of Congress as a valid elected representative deserving respect—meeting everyone, including those who only wanted to yell, and traveling weekly to their districts—built a bipartisan, bicameral majority within a year, whereas the common advice to 'fight the good fight' was the wrong metaphor.
“I knew instinctively that fighting was the wrong metaphor, that my job was to reconcile.”
- The best thing Gioia did as NEA chairman was to change the agency so that for the first time in its history it reached every community and population—representing all of America rather than largely serving the artistic elite—even though the arts world was angry about it.
“we were representing, for the first time in the history of the agency, all of America. We were reaching every community, every population, versus an institution that was largely serving the artistic elite.”
- A museum is fundamentally a conservation technology—a roughly 200-year-old institution born after the French Revolution to preserve the best of the past and let people into it; today's museums err by reconceiving themselves as 'vehicles of cultural change,' which misunderstands their basic function, since dedicated art spaces (kunsthalle, galleries, exhibitions) already exist for that purpose.
“a museum is a conservation technology. The museum is a relatively modern creation. It really happens only after the French revolution”
- Lukács's analysis in History and Class Consciousness holds that humans create an institution for a social use (e.g., a legal system for justice), but as the institution develops and seeks internal consistency it has less and less to do with its original purpose, becoming a self-contained rational enterprise; literary studies reached this point ~50 years ago, becoming internally cohesive while having almost nothing to do with the human purposes of literature.
“humans create an institution... for a social use called justice. As the legal system develops... it has less and less to do with justice because it’s more concerned, in a sense, about being a self-contained, rational enterprise.”
- Academic culture has one or two trendy approaches it deems important because they generate work that validates scholars for promotion and tenure, as opposed to work expressing deeper cultural values.
“there’s one or two trendy ways that they think are important because they generate work that validates you for promotion and for tenure versus having real deeper cultural values.”
Art builds upon enduring works and cultural memory rather than discarding the past for novelty.
- The whole notion of art is one of conservation: looking at all the achievements of the past, figuring out what to save and what to add to move forward—just as in mathematics, science, or economics you would not throw out everything before you but build on it to make something meaningful for the moment.
“The whole notion seems to me of art is of conservation, of looking at all the achievements of the past and figuring out what it is we save and what it is that we need to add to move forward.”
- Early Christianity cannot be understood without Virgil: Christians read his Eclogue prophecy of a savior-king as a natural prophecy, and through Virgil they were able to save the entire classical tradition as an alternate way of thinking, digesting it into Catholicism—which is why Catholicism has such a strong philosophical, theological, and artistic tradition.
“Using Virgil they were able to save the entire classical tradition as an alternate way of thinking about the world... which is why Catholicism has such a strong philosophical-theological and artistic tradition.”
- Augustus understood the cultural power of art: a culture or empire holds together only by certain common myths that convey shared values not in intellectual terms but through story, emotion, and image; giving people a common story unifies them, which is what Virgil and Horace did and why postmodernist dismissals of them as imperial pawns miss the point.
“if you can give people a common story, it unifies them. A culture, in order to keep together an empire, a nation in order to keep together, has to have certain common myths that express, convey the values, not in intellectual terms, but in terms of story, emotion, image.”
- The non-obvious advice for becoming deeply knowledgeable is to pay attention to what genuinely interests you rather than to novelty-driven commercial culture, and to punk yourself out of the daily ephemeral culture (e.g., the 90 minutes a day students spend on tweets) and immerse in things still present in 10 or 100 years—because without a point of perspective from the past you can understand neither the present nor anything else.
“Punk yourself out of the daily ephemeral culture and immerse yourself into things that are going to be still there 10 years later or 100 years later.”
- Memorizing poetry is the only way to learn it: the mother of the muses is Mnemosyne, goddess of memory, and you do not understand poetry until you learn it by heart—putting it into the center of your being makes you grasp how most of poetry's meaning is indirect, intuitive, even physical.
“Memorizing poetry is the only way to learn poetry. Who is the mother of the muses? Mnemosyne, the goddess of memory. You don’t understand poetry until you learn it by heart.”
- Gioia's current intellectual practice is to go back and relearn things he already knew—spending months rereading everything by Baudelaire to write a 14,000-word introduction was illuminating and joyful—because deep re-immersion in a known author yields fresh insight a creative writer can use.
“I knew Baudelaire’s work but spending several months rereading absolutely everything was, to me, illuminating and joyful.”
Humanistic knowledge and broad literacy enable creative problem-solving that technical training alone cannot achieve.
- MBA programs neglect the humanities for two reasons: the American educational system ignores the humanities, and the larger culture ignores them; business school people are practical and get things done but generally lack broad historical/humanistic knowledge and are not terribly creative.
“One is that the American educational system ignores the humanities, and secondly, our larger culture ignores the humanities.”
- High-level literacy is measured by whether people can recognize contradictory statements in a logical structure (e.g., 'coffee is good' vs 'coffee is bad'); many people, due to inadequate linguistic training, cannot do this, meaning we have lost the ability to make basic distinctions and refinements in thought—reflected in coarsening language, cliches, news bites, and shrinking article lengths.
“They cannot because of their, in a sense, inadequate linguistic training, they cannot recognize contradictory statements in a logical structure, which means that we’ve lost our ability to make even basic distinctions and refinements in terms of thought.”
- Large analytic, militarily-organized companies excel at running existing businesses efficiently but fail at reconceptualizing troubled businesses; the rare and valuable combination is creativity that is fully in command of the numbers—taking an existing solution apart and building a new one.
“What they were not good at was, in a sense, reconceptualizing a business that was in trouble, because they would simply try to do more or less of what they had done before.”
- Working among intelligent nonliterary people in business for 15 years changed Gioia's sense of language and audience, making him a better poet than he would have been had he stayed in the university, where most poets remain in a schoolroom worldview their entire lives.
“most poets in the United States have been in school since they were 6. At 65, they’re still in school, their whole vision of the world is of a schoolroom, of a university. I was basically working with very intelligent, nonliterary people for 15 years.”
Greatest art awakens human potential by unlocking emotional, intellectual, and spiritual capacities within audiences.
- The greatest paintings have an extraordinary intellectual, emotional, and spiritual power: if you put yourself in their presence repeatedly, they unlock and awaken things inside of you, which is why Gioia returns again and again to the same works in museums.
“there is an extraordinary intellectual, emotional, and spiritual power that the greatest paintings have. If you put yourself in their presence, they unlock and awaken things inside of you.”
- Art exists to increase human happiness on an individual level by awakening people to their own potential; poetry specifically awakens emotions and the ability to articulate them, so on a social level its function is to enlarge our empathy and understanding of one another by producing people more aware of who they are and able to recognize that empathetically in others.
“the reason that we have art is, in a sense, to increase human happiness. It does that, essentially, on an individual level. A work of art awakens you.”
- Tolstoy is the greatest fiction writer who ever lived, and The Death of Ivan Ilyich is one of the greatest considerations of human mortality and limitation ever written; among works read together with family, Anna Karenina stands above everything else as unmatched in greatness.
“if you asked me who was the greatest fiction writer who ever lived, I would say Tolstoy.”
Reconceptualizing existing art forms for new audiences solves cultural decline better than incremental iteration.
- Jell-O and other packaged foods had declined for decades because companies kept trying to do more or less of what they had always done; the fix was taking older products and making them relevant to people who weren't using them regularly.
“Jell-O had been declining because all packaged foods had been declining... It was a sense of taking these older products and making them relevant to people that weren’t using them all the time.”
- The Jell-O Jiggler doubled the declining business overnight by reconceptualizing Jell-O from an elaborate recipe into a quick mom-and-kid finger-food activity (homemade gummy bears), using three times as much Jell-O for occasions where people previously wouldn't use it at all.
“It was the way of using three times as much Jell-O for an occasion in which people would never use Jell-O, which is to make your own gummy bears. It became a mom-kid activity. We sold every box of Jell-O in the United States for several months.”
- Intellectuals in the mid-20th century took poetry away from common people by removing rhyme, meter, narrative, and the ballad, making it appeal only to an elite; the common people then reinvented it from the ground up—Kool Herc inventing rap and hip hop in the South Bronx, plus slam poetry, cowboy poetry, and new formalism—amounting to a reinvention of popular oral poetry akin to Homer within our own lifetime.
“What the intellectuals in the United States did was we took poetry away from common people. We took rhyme away, we took narrative away, we took the ballad away, and the common people reinvented it.”
Decentralized funding and artist accessibility across class and profession create healthier cultural ecosystems.
- Getting arts funding closer to the people is generally better than centralizing it; having 53 state arts agencies means 53 different strategies, revealing the advantage of the federal system where different people try different things and learn from each other.
“you’ve got 53 state arts agencies, which means you’ve got 53 different strategies. You start to see the advantages of the federal system, where different people try different things and then they learn from each other.”
- Gioia's poetry is written for people with broad life experience—the older and more diverse the audience the better—rather than for the insular tribe of poets with their own rituals, because intelligent and reflective people exist in every profession including manual labor, and the assumption that the common reader is stupid is false.
“my poetry is written for people with broad life experience. The older the audience, the better the audience. The more diverse the audience, the better the audience.”
- Gioia prefers ground-level Catholicism—a working-class, immigrant, Mexican and Filipino parish in shambles over the prosperous upper-middle-class one—because he believes his church is the church of the poor and the immigrant, an identification reawakened at St. Patrick's in Washington where homeless, overeducated, and hotel-service worshippers were together.
“I like ground-level Catholicism. I believe that my church is the church of the poor. The church of the immigrant.”
Living donors who remain actively engaged and measure results provide better institutional stewardship than passive endowments.
- The best arts funding comes from the private sector when people give money while still alive so they can measure results and become actively involved, bringing their organizational and judgment skills; figures like Carnegie, Mellon, and Huntington who built institutions while alive transformed cultural landscapes, whereas today wealthy people defer giving to posthumous foundations and direct what they do give toward medicine or science rather than the arts.
“It’s where people give money while they’re still alive so they can measure the results of what they’re doing. I believe that people should fund things in their own communities and they should become very actively involved.”
- It is heartbreaking and damaging for museums to sell their best paintings to cover deficits from their own bad management or to buy more socially proactive works, because these institutions will never be able to get those works back; if boards want socially proactive works, the board should buy them rather than selling the existing collection.
“It breaks my heart to see museums sell their best paintings to raise money to, first of all, cover the deficits of their own bad management.”
Deprivation of narrative and aesthetic experience contributes to epidemic suicide and addiction rates.
- The suicide and opioid epidemics in the United States, especially among young people, afflict people who cannot get control of the stories of their own lives; the deprivation and cheapening of narrative in mass culture has had a tremendous human cost in lost creativity and productivity and, at worst, in suicide, drug use, and death.
“I believe that the suicide epidemic in the United States, the opioid epidemic in the United States, especially among young people, is among people who cannot, in a sense, get control of the stories of their own lives.”
Authentic human experience requires an undercurrent of loss and mortality to be sustaining.
- As jazz musicians say, you have to pay your dues: if your art isn't good enough that you're willing to suffer and sacrifice for it, you're not getting deeply enough down inside yourself.
“I do believe, as the jazz musicians say, you got to pay your dues. If your art isn’t so good that you’re willing to suffer for it, willing to sacrifice for it, you’re not getting deeply enough down inside you.”
- The Beach Boys' greatest songs are among the high points of American popular music, especially valuable now because they are among the purest expressions of a personal and collective optimism America once had about the goodness of life—an optimism we have lost to our detriment.
“they are in some ways the purest expressions of a personal and collective optimism that America had about, in a sense, the goodness of life, and we’ve lost that to our detriment.”
- All great happy art has an undercut of sadness, captured by the phrase Et in Arcadia ego (even in paradise, death is present); Renaissance painters placed a small skull beneath a bush in beautiful landscapes, and any artist must reconcile the sorrows of life—as Brian Wilson's increasingly paralyzing melancholy illustrates.
“I think that all great happy art has an undercut of sadness and any artist has to, in a sense, reconcile the sorrows, the sadness of it.”
- For a young artist there is no substitute for the experience of being in the presence of a master; Bishop was a bad teacher with no pretensions, but simply being in a room with a great poet looking at poems together was transformative—just as seeing how jazz great Stan Getz worked was like a university degree.
“there is no substitute for a young artist to the experience of being in the presence of a master.”
- The fundamental comic idea beneath Laurel and Hardy and W. C. Fields is how thwarted we are in getting through the ordinary business of our day—Fields can't get a cup of coffee or take a nap without trouble—an existential humor invisible to a young viewer who only sees the jokes.
“the fundamental comic idea under them, is how thwarted we are getting through the ordinary business of our day.”
Individual artists achieve greatness through aliveness and intensity even without perfecting their complete works.
- Composers manipulate the pacing of musical time to opposite effects: Verdi's Rigoletto rushes through to create emotional frenzy and excitation, while Wagner's Tristan slows time to produce a hypnotic, trance-like effect—though in Parsifal that slowing goes too far.
“I would take Verdi’s Rigoletto, where he just rushes through this thing and it puts you in an emotional frenzy... where Wagner slowed down time to give you a very different almost hypnotic effect of the music. One’s emotional excitation, the other is a kind of hypnotic trance.”
- Verdi's Otello is at least the equal of Shakespeare's play dramatically, possessing theatrical moments Shakespeare lacks—Iago's blasphemous Credo to a God of evil and Desdemona's Ave Maria—making it the greatest of all Shakespearean operas, with Falstaff a close second and itself a gerontologist's miracle composed when Verdi was 80.
“It’s certainly the equal of Shakespeare’s play. It has things that Shakespeare — It has the thing called the Credo, where Yago comes in and does a blasphemous parody of the Catholic Credo”
- Olaf Stapledon was a clumsy but visionary early science fiction writer who was the first to think in absolutely cosmic terms—beyond human conceptions of time and space—thereby creating the mature science fiction sensibility that still shapes works like The Expanse.
“he was the first really great science fiction writer to think in absolutely cosmic terms, beyond human conceptions of time and space. That, essentially, created the mature science fiction sensibility.”
- Anthony Burgess, like D. H. Lawrence, was unquestionably a great writer who may never have written a single fully great novel—though Earthly Powers may be the exception that works from first page to last—because the value lies in the aliveness of almost every page rather than the perfection of the whole.
“Anthony Burgess is like D. H. Lawrence... a great writer. The question is, did he ever write a great novel?... the fact about Burgess is that almost every page is alive.”
Catholicism shapes artistic and intellectual tradition through sacramental vision and cultural memory.
- America has a tremendous Catholic fiction culture largely produced by converts or sympathizers—Willa Cather (not Catholic) wrote perhaps the best American Catholic novel, Death Comes for the Archbishop—and by southerners like Flannery O'Connor, Walker Percy, and John Kennedy Toole who belonged to a discriminated minority; there is a current revival (Tobias Wolff, Ron Hansen, Alice McDermott) alongside a surprising Protestant-novel revival in Marilynne Robinson, though Catholic voices are not yet mainstream.
“We have a tremendous Catholic culture in American fiction that was largely done by converts, or people that were sympathetic. Willa Cather, who was not Catholic wrote Death Comes for the Archbishop, maybe the best Catholic novel in American literature.”
- Catholic worship was originally built on chant in Latin, which grew distant from common populations, producing by the Reformation a gap between Catholicism as a sacramental religion and the charismatic religion the Protestants invented; Catholicism has never really caught up musically with that charismatic tradition.
“there was this great gap between, in a sense, a sacramental religion and what the Protestants invented, which was a charismatic religion. Catholicism has never really caught up with that”
- Catholic poetry is shaped by the sacraments—outward signs symbolizing inward turns of grace—so a Catholic sees everything in two ways at once: physical and metaphysical, temporal and eternal; for Gioia's generation, being raised with Latin meant hearing in English the echoes of an ancient language, creating continuity between a working-class childhood and the court of Augustus.
“a Catholic sees everything that happens in two ways: in a physical way and a metaphysical way, in a temporal way and an eternal way, with all of the mysterious connections between that.”
- The strongest recent presence of Catholicism in American fine arts is in movies: Italian-American filmmakers like Coppola, Scorsese, and Cimino brought a dark Catholic worldview into American popular culture in works such as Mean Streets, The Godfather, and The Deer Hunter, which are fundamentally sacramental works of art.
“The Italian-American filmmakers like Coppola, Scorsese, Cimino, in a sense, brought a dark Catholic worldview into American popular culture.”
Redemptive spiritual vision matters for art; works must struggle from darkness toward convincing redemption.
- The California dream Brian Wilson and historian Kevin Starr celebrated has fallen apart; the detrimental economic, cultural, and educational changes in California over the last 15-20 years have been so extreme that it is heartbreaking for native residents, even though it remains a beautiful place to live.
“the detrimental aspects of California economically, culturally educationally have been so extreme in the last 15–20 years. It’s heartbreaking for people here.”
- When a film locates itself in hell from the start (e.g. Chan-wook Park's Oldboy), it struggles to get out, because we are not redeemed by the blood we ourselves spill—so such films lack convincing redemptions despite their sin and suffering.
“when you begin and you locate your films in hell, how do you get out of it? I don’t necessarily find those films having convincing redemptions. I don’t think we’re redeemed by the blood that we ourselves spill.”
- Catholicism gives sensible management advice—you must love everyone—but loving them does not mean everyone is perfect; the task is to manage love, community, and shared responsibility together with the ability to criticize people so they can transcend their current state and become better versions of themselves.
“you must love everyone. But that doesn’t mean that everyone’s perfect. You have to, in a sense, manage love, community, togetherness, shared responsibility with an ability to criticize people so they can transcend their current state”