Dynamical Independence
Barnett and Seth's criterion that a candidate weakly emergent macroscopic variable is one whose future cannot be better predicted by knowing the microscopic state than by the macroscopic variable itself; used to discover emergent coarse-grainings.
As defined in 168 | Anil Seth on Emergence, Information, and Consciousness
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “Dynamical Independence” →
- Top-down or downward causation can be accommodated in the dynamical-independence framework in a metaphysically innocent way: instead of positing competing macro-level causes that fight micro-level causes, one simply asks whether, from an observer's standpoint, the macroscopic variable helps predict the evolution of the microscopic components better than the microscopic components alone—and empirically, bird flocks do show information flow from flock to birds that random flying does not.168 | Anil Seth on Emergence, Information, and Consciousness
- In the Barnett-Seth approach, a candidate weakly emergent macroscopic variable must be dynamically independent from its microscopic underpinnings, meaning that knowing what is going on at the microscopic level does not help you predict the macroscopic variable's evolution; this enables data-driven discovery of candidate emergent coarse-grainings even when the emergent property does not visibly leap out to an observer.168 | Anil Seth on Emergence, Information, and Consciousness
- Emergence in the dynamical-independence sense is best understood as a way to enrich our descriptions of physical systems in ways that might be relevant to consciousness—since conscious experiences are unified, global, and seem more than the sum of their parts—rather than as a proof that consciousness is an emergent property; it is an empirical question whether weakly emergent properties dissolve when people lose consciousness under anesthesia or sleep.168 | Anil Seth on Emergence, Information, and Consciousness
- Against critics who claim you could never find tables and chairs (or consciousness) by starting from atoms without importing a richer ontology, the dynamical-independence framework provides equations specifying the conditions under which emergent macroscopic structures appear, so higher-level entities can in principle be derived rather than assumed.168 | Anil Seth on Emergence, Information, and Consciousness
- In the space of all imaginable systems, genuine emergence—the existence of higher-level descriptions as good at predicting the future as possible without extra microscopic information—is probably rare; a randomly chosen coarse-graining is unlikely to be emergent, and a system of non-interacting random particles should yield a flat emergence measure, which is the desired behavior for any candidate metric.168 | Anil Seth on Emergence, Information, and Consciousness