factual
Downward Causation Without Metaphysical Mischief
Top-down or downward causation can be accommodated in the dynamical-independence framework in a metaphysically innocent way: instead of positing competing macro-level causes that fight micro-level causes, one simply asks whether, from an observer's standpoint, the macroscopic variable helps predict the evolution of the microscopic components better than the microscopic components alone—and empirically, bird flocks do show information flow from flock to birds that random flying does not.
factualpending
Speaker
Anil SethEvidence Quote
“when you have a bird flock, you do observe information flow from the flock to the individual birds in a way that you don't when they're all flying randomly around.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:14:09 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...