Decision journal
A record-keeping system where decision-makers document the outcome of a decision, the main arguments pro and con, alternatives considered, and their confidence level; used for later debriefing and identifying patterns in decision quality
As defined in Daniel Kahneman | The Knowledge Project #68
Other definitions
A personal record where someone writes down a decision, the goals they're trying to achieve, the key information they're using, what they're noticing, what's driving the decision, and who will be affected, allowing retrospective learning about missed cues and unconsidered factors.
Insights for Making Better Decisions | Gary Klein | Knowledge Project 144
Where it comes up · 3
- Daniel Kahneman | The Knowledge Project #682 claims
- Jim Collins — Good to Great — The Knowledge Project #672 claims
- Insights for Making Better Decisions | Gary Klein | Knowledge Project 1441 claim
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “Decision journal” →
- Parrish uses decision journals where he writes down his decisions in advance and then evaluates them afterward; he finds that people are often right on outcome but wrong on reasoning—they rationalize why they were right when the actual reasons were differentJim Collins — Good to Great — The Knowledge Project #67
- Decision journals—written records of decisions including the decision itself, goals, prime information used, what's being noticed, what's driving the decision, and affected stakeholders—create a record of thinking at the time, allowing retrospective learning about missed cues and unconsidered goals.Insights for Making Better Decisions | Gary Klein | Knowledge Project 144
- Decision-making cannot be reduced to a single learnable skill or checklist; instead, effectiveness comes from understanding that all decisions are contextual, requiring intelligent preparation beforehand (anticipating likely decision types and relevant knowledge), deliberate attention to one's decision process rather than just outcomes, separation of decision quality from outcome luck, and systematic learning from past decisions via decision journals.Jim Collins — Good to Great — The Knowledge Project #67
- Decision journals and pre-mortems are tools that can identify people whose judgment is better than their manager's, allowing for consistent calibration of judgment quality over time and potentially surfacing hidden talent or exposing managerial errors without social friction.Daniel Kahneman | The Knowledge Project #68
- A decision journal should record the main arguments pro and con, the alternative options considered, and the decision-maker's confidence level in the decision; this creates a record sufficient for later debriefing yourself and learning whether your judgment process is improving.Daniel Kahneman | The Knowledge Project #68