Chinese room
John Searle's thought experiment in which a person manipulating Chinese symbols by rules without understanding them is meant to show that symbol manipulation alone does not produce genuine understanding.
As defined in AMA | August 2022
Other definitions
John Searle's thought experiment in which a person follows rules to produce correct Chinese responses without understanding Chinese; used here to describe speaking correct words about a subject without genuinely knowing it.
Adam Mastroianni on the Brain, the Ears, and How We Learn
Where it comes up · 4
- Machine Intelligence and Risk Management1 claim
- Adam Mastroianni on the Brain, the Ears, and How We Learn1 claim
- 53 - The Dawn Of Artificial Intelligence1 claim
- AMA | August 20221 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “Chinese room” →
- There are escalating levels of knowing: being able to recapitulate the knowledge, being able to spot it in the world, and the deepest level where you behave differently from someone who doesn't know it—you truly know something only when you take it seriously enough that it changes your behavior; merely speaking the right words when prompted is being a 'Chinese room.'Adam Mastroianni on the Brain, the Ears, and How We Learn
- Reducing an algorithm to inputs, outputs, and rules strips away the sense of magic, and intelligence is partly defined as that magic, so exposing the mechanism cheapens what we call intelligent.Machine Intelligence and Risk Management
- The correct response to Searle's Chinese Room is that while the person inside does not understand Chinese, the room as a whole does; the thought experiment merely pumps intuitions by mapping the brain's billions of neurons onto slow punch cards, making a conscious system seem implausible, but if there is nothing more to the brain than its neurons and cells, one must accept the room understands Chinese.AMA | August 2022
- Strong AI, a term from John Searle, originally meant that building human-level intelligence inevitably produces a conscious device because the functional properties of intelligence and consciousness are inseparable, while weak AI builds systems with desired capabilities without necessarily having consciousness; modern usage shifts 'strong'/'general' AI to mean human-or-greater capabilities with no claim about consciousness, and 'narrow' AI to mean systems lacking generality.53 - The Dawn Of Artificial Intelligence