Central Advisory Commission
An institutional power center of retired Communist Party leaders who retained informal influence over current leaders; abolished after 1989 to centralize power in the General Secretary position
As defined in The Rise and Fall of the EAST: Yasheng Huang in Conversation with Orville Schell
Where it comes up · 2
- Critical Issues Confronting China - Professor Yasheng Huang - November 29, 20238 claims
- The Rise and Fall of the EAST: Yasheng Huang in Conversation with Orville Schell2 claims
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “Central Advisory Commission” →
- In the 1980s, despite being an economic hardship era for many, China experienced political power fragmentation with five separate power centers (Communist Party General Secretary, President, Military Affairs Commission Chairman, Premier, and Central Advisory Commission), which created a de facto system of checks and balances, however crude, that constrained any single leader's ability to consolidate absolute power.The Rise and Fall of the EAST: Yasheng Huang in Conversation with Orville Schell
- In the 1980s, China had five roughly equal centers of power (General Secretary, President, Premier, Chairman of Central Military Commission, and Chairman of Central Advisory Commission) with meaningful checks and balances between individual leaders, rather than institutional separation of powers.Critical Issues Confronting China - Professor Yasheng Huang - November 29, 2023
- Huang acknowledges that institutionalizing the Central Advisory Commission could have evolved differently over time; founding members' heavy-handedness was inevitable but would have diminished with new members and institutional norm-setting; institutions work out their problems when there is incentive to write rules of the game.Critical Issues Confronting China - Professor Yasheng Huang - November 29, 2023
- The Central Advisory Commission's constraint power depended on the personal willingness and health of individuals like Jiang Zemin, not on institutionalized mechanisms; this personal basis was Huang's point about why abolishing the institution matters—it shifted from institutional to individual capacity-based constraint.Critical Issues Confronting China - Professor Yasheng Huang - November 29, 2023
- After 1989, power distribution collapsed from five centers to two centers; the Central Advisory Commission was abolished; party branches were reinserted into State-Owned Enterprises and government agencies; and all major political reforms of the 1980s were explicitly reversed.Critical Issues Confronting China - Professor Yasheng Huang - November 29, 2023
- The Central Advisory Commission, created by Deng Xiaoping in 1982-1983, provided a formal institutionalized platform for retired elders to exercise constraint (participation power, not decision power) on the incumbent leadership, serving a similar function to the House of Lords in British politics.Critical Issues Confronting China - Professor Yasheng Huang - November 29, 2023
- In autocracies, the only people the current autocrat is accountable to are his predecessors; the Central Advisory Commission created in the 1980s was an institutional base for retired leaders to exercise constraint over successors, and Deng Xiaoping's abolition of it in 1989 removed the only structural check on successors' powerThe Rise and Fall of the EAST: Yasheng Huang in Conversation with Orville Schell
- Funding families (founding elite families like the Deng, Ma, Chen Yun, Bo, and Chen families) agreed to power-sharing arrangements after the revolution to guarantee their descendants would also have a share of power; the Central Advisory Commission institutionalized this family-based power sharing.Critical Issues Confronting China - Professor Yasheng Huang - November 29, 2023
- Once the Central Advisory Commission was abolished, the only constraint on the incumbent was informal check-and-balance by individual predecessors in their personal capacity, making such constraint dependent on their health and longevity rather than institutional design.Critical Issues Confronting China - Professor Yasheng Huang - November 29, 2023
- Had the Central Advisory Commission still existed as an institution in 2018, it would have been more difficult for Xi Jinping to abolish constitutional term limits; the counterfactual question of whether the institution could have constrained this move cannot be definitively answered but is historically significant.Critical Issues Confronting China - Professor Yasheng Huang - November 29, 2023