Altruism
Behavior that benefits others at a cost to oneself; in evolutionary biology, a trait disadvantageous to the individual but potentially advantageous to the group.
As defined in Michael Munger on Desires, Morality, and Self-Interest
Other definitions
In Allison's (Objectivist) usage, a moral demand to sacrifice oneself for others. He uses it in this sense rather than to mean simple kindness or charity.
John Allison on Strategy, Profits, and Self-Interest 5/7/2007
Where it comes up · 6
- John Allison on Strategy, Profits, and Self-Interest 5/7/20073 claims
- Yaron Brook (Ayn Rand Institute) US Is Now Atlas Shrugged, Will We See Socialism Next?3 claims
- 113 | Cailin O'Connor on Game Theory, Evolution, and the Origins of Unfairness3 claims
- John Gray on the Seven Kinds of Atheism2 claims
- Jennifer Burns on Ayn Rand and the Goddess of the Market1 claim
- Michael Munger on Desires, Morality, and Self-Interest1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 13Search all claims for “Altruism” →
- The deep reason the prisoner's dilemma is so fascinating is that it is essentially an analysis of altruism: cooperating lowers your own payoff while raising others', which is materially altruistic, yet the game's structure says altruism is not individually rational—so the puzzle is why we observe so much altruism in humans and animals.113 | Cailin O'Connor on Game Theory, Evolution, and the Origins of Unfairness
- Altruism that seems individually irrational is explained by two mechanisms: repeated interactions change the game's structure so cooperating now can be rational because it elicits future cooperation, and kin selection means genes for altruism are favored because altruists directed toward kin are disproportionately helping other altruists who share those genes.113 | Cailin O'Connor on Game Theory, Evolution, and the Origins of Unfairness
- Rand did not oppose voluntary altruism but believed it should not be the essence of morality or held up as a standard by teachers of ethics; she subsumed charity far down under free choice, fearing that elevating altruism gives political leaders and statist systems the moral ground to justify confiscation in the name of helping others.Jennifer Burns on Ayn Rand and the Goddess of the Market
- John Maynard Smith's game-theoretic models showed it is hard to get group selection for altruism to work, but the literature wrongly generalized this to conclude group selection is unimportant for everything; the correct conclusion is only that group selection probably is not the main explanation of altruism, not that it is unimportant for explaining other traits.113 | Cailin O'Connor on Game Theory, Evolution, and the Origins of Unfairness
- Per E.O. Wilson, evolution is a contest between two forces: any selfish individual will dominate any altruistic individual (a drawback for the altruist), but any group of altruists will dominate any group of selfish individuals because they trust each other, cooperate, are happier, reproduce more, and have lower contracting costs—creating a permanent tension between individual and group selection.Michael Munger on Desires, Morality, and Self-Interest
- Self-sacrifice is also self-defeating. Altruism demands a movement to the lowest common denominator: whoever has more must give to whoever has less, recursively, and since someone is always dying, the only way to be equal to them is to die yourself. Medieval monks who whipped themselves and drank dirty dishwater illustrate taking this seriously.John Allison on Strategy, Profits, and Self-Interest 5/7/2007
- Typical corporate value statements contain bromides and cliches that are forms of altruism. Businesses in a free market cannot actually be altruistic and stay in business, so employees know the company doesn't mean it. They then search for the real operating principles, meaning what actually gets rewarded and gets you ahead, and follow those instead.John Allison on Strategy, Profits, and Self-Interest 5/7/2007
- The proper foundation for morality is being honest with yourself about your strengths and weaknesses, and if your skills suit production, then pursuing that productively is more moral than immediate altruism because it generates more good for others and yourself.Yaron Brook (Ayn Rand Institute) US Is Now Atlas Shrugged, Will We See Socialism Next?
- Historically most atheists in modern Western atheism have not been liberals but anti-liberals—racists, Bolsheviks, Nietzscheans—so present-day atheists deserve no credit for picking a good liberal morality; they simply absorbed the one they grew up with, as illustrated by Ayn Rand's exaltation of egoism, Comte's invention of altruism, and Julian Huxley's racist writings that reversed only when the consequences became evident.John Gray on the Seven Kinds of Atheism
- The shift in morality from altruism to egoism is necessary, and Ayn Rand (alongside but extending Aristotle) is the most important thinker in this tradition of egoismYaron Brook (Ayn Rand Institute) US Is Now Atlas Shrugged, Will We See Socialism Next?