definition

Instinct Connotes Automata Not Humility

Whereas Roberts hears 'instinct' as a humble admission of ignorance, Webb hears it as implying automata—creatures with no choice, behavior reduced to pre-programmed genetics—which is a shame because any behavior can be explained at multiple levels of analysis, and a genetic or molecular explanation does not preclude consciousness, will, intention, or planning as additional valid layers.

definitionpending

Speaker

Christine Webb

Evidence Quote

“just because you can explain it there doesn't mean that I'm not conscious of doing it, or that I'm not having will, or intention, or planning, or a desire.”

Source

Humans Are Overrated (with Christine Webb)— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:12:35 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...