Smith identifies an 'irregularity of sentiment': although philosophically praise and blame ought to depend only on intentions/effort, in practice we assign far more praise or blame based on actual consequences and how fortune (chance) falls—e.g., the architect with only a blueprint, the general with an unimplemented plan, the friend who solicits a job that never materializes, the messenger of bad news, two stones thrown over a wall with different outcomes, or a shot that wounds versus kills—even though effort was identical.
factualpending
Speaker
Dan KleinEvidence Quote
“what he's got in this section as I read it is essentially a great many examples of what he calls this irregularity of sentiment”
Source
Dan Klein on The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Episode 3--A Discussion of Part II 04/22/2009— EconTalkCreated: 6/16/2026, 2:17:22 PM
Your notes
Loading notes...