When S&P made an error adding a stock to a narrow dividend-focused index and then removing it days later, the stock experienced a 7% price swing solely due to the indexation decision, demonstrating that membership effects are economically significant even in niche indexes.

factualpending

Speaker

Rob Arnott

Evidence Quote

“the stock qu from 84 to 90 and then back down to 84 that's a 7 plus% move for a little niche index [50:05]”

Source

Value Had One of Its Worst Periods in History | What Data Tells Us Comes Next— Excess Returns
Created: 8/11/2026, 7:08:29 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...