normative
State Intervenes When Parental Choices Harm Children
Autonomous competent adults may make self-regarding healthcare decisions including refusal of treatment, and parents may make decisions for their young children, but parental discretion is not unlimited: when faith-healing or similar choices put a child at high risk of permanent serious injury or death, the state steps in—paralleling how society removes children from abusive parents—because the irreconcilable belief now harms someone who could not consent.
normativepending
Speaker
Alta CharoEvidence Quote
“Where we change the rules is not on where your irreconcilable difference affects you and you alone, it's where it affects somebody else who in no way is in a position to have welcomed this kind of decision for themselves”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:20:27 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...