causal

Constitutional Order Must Precede the Mass Age

Constitutional order and rule of law can only take root if instituted before the mass age—as in England, the US, and France—when the franchise is restricted to property-holding men, giving a breathing space to embed constitutionalism that can later be democratized; once peasants, workers, and nationalist movements are politically mobilized, constitutional order alone is insufficient for them and the revolution radicalizes leftward.

causalpending

Speaker

Stephen Kotkin

Evidence Quote

“It had to have happened beforehand, before the modern era. Why? Because when you institute constitutional order, like in England, in the US, to a certain extent in France... you do it before you're in the mass age. You do it before the working class and the peasantry are politically organized... You have this restricted franchise, which is like a breathing space for you to introduce and get used to a liberal constitutional order that you can then democratize over time.”

Source

Stephen Kotkin — How Stalin became the most powerful dictator in history— Dwarkesh Patel Podcast
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:31:58 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...