factual

Action-reaction objection to pilot wave is special pleading

The objection that pilot-wave theory violates a 'generalized Newton's third law' because the wave guides the particles but the particles don't influence the wave is special pleading — even in Newtonian gravity the law of gravity affects particles without the particles changing the law, so it is not a general truth that if A affects B, B must reciprocally affect A.

factualpending

Speaker

Tim Maudlin

Evidence Quote

“we don't usually think that if A affects B, B has to have a reciprocal back effect on A... So this seems to me to be a bit special pleading of trying to find something to complain about.”

Source

241 | Tim Maudlin on Locality, Hidden Variables, and Quantum Foundations— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:22:53 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...