factual

Aumann's theorem: rational agents cannot agree to disagree

Aumann's Agreement Theorem proves that two rational Bayesian agents with the same priors who make their posteriors common knowledge must arrive at the same posterior—they cannot agree to disagree—even without sharing the underlying evidence, because each should update on the mere fact of the other rational agent's stated credence.

factualpending

Speaker

Steven Pinker

Evidence Quote

“Two rational agents with the same priors in the Bayesian sense of their credence in a hypothesis before they've even looked at the evidence... who then make their posteriors common knowledge... those posteriors must be the same. That is, it is, they cannot agree to disagree.”

Source

329 | Steven Pinker on Rationality and Common Knowledge— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:10:03 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...