causal

Kalam Argument's First Premise Is False

The Kalam cosmological argument fails not because we know the universe didn't begin (that's open) but because its first premise — everything that begins to exist has a cause — is false; cause and effect is an emergent, entropy-dependent concept of the macroscopic world, while fundamental physics is described by differential equations with no cause-and-effect law, so the correct statement is 'the universe obeys the laws of physics,' which yields no 'therefore God.'

causalpending

Speaker

Sean Carroll

Evidence Quote

“the point is you don't say everything that begins to exist has a cause, you say everything obeys the laws of physics. And once you say it that way, you're not going to get to God existing.”

Source

AMA | August 2021— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:35:09 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...