normative

Human-vs-Alien Civilization Value Is a Toss-Up

MacAskill holds it as roughly a toss-up whether a human-originating future civilization would be more valuable than an alien-originating one, but because he weights both an impartial view and a more partial pro-human view, he gives some extra weight to human-originating civilization while refusing to favor humans by extreme ratios like 10,000 to 1.

normativepending

Speaker

William MacAskill

Evidence Quote

“I have two moral perspectives that I’m putting some weight on. One says aliens have as good a chance of producing a great civilization as humans do. The second is the more partial view which would weight humans above aliens.”

Source

William MacAskill— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:31:00 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...