factual

Pettenkofer Was Right and Wrong Simultaneously

Max von Pettenkofer made the great CO2 discovery yet was incredibly wrong about airborne infection — a committed miasma champion who swallowed a tube of cholera to 'prove' it wasn't waterborne and survived — demonstrating that science does not follow a neat path and that a person can be brilliant on one fact and badly mistaken on another.

factualpending

Speaker

Carl Zimmer

Evidence Quote

“he was also incredibly wrong about a fundamental fact about airborne infection. Science just doesn’t follow a neat path the way we’d like.”

Source

Carl Zimmer— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:04:32 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...