causal

Civility Used as a Cudgel to Silence Debate

Civility talk is often used as a cudgel to shut down debate—accusing someone of incivility places them 'beyond the pale' (a phrase originating in the fence dividing civilized Dublin from the 'barbarous' Catholics outside)—allowing us to avoid arguing why opponents are wrong; both accusing someone of incivility and being uncivil toward them function to expel them from the community of respectable conversationalists.

causalpending

Speaker

Teresa Bejan

Evidence Quote

“when we accuse someone of incivility, we place them implicitly beyond the pale”

Source

116 | Teresa Bejan on Free Speech, Civility, and Toleration— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:13:01 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...