normative
Some Clear Provisions Are Indefensible Today
Some unambiguous constitutional provisions produce bad outcomes almost no one would defend today: District of Columbia residents are ruled directly by Congress with no vote, and presidential electors are legally free to vote for anyone, even someone soundly defeated or not on the ballot—both arrangements are appalling and nutty 18th-century judgments we are effectively stuck with.
normativepending
Speaker
Louis Michael SeidmanEvidence Quote
“So we are stuck with these nutty 18th-century judgments.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:24:36 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...