causal
Severe Punishments Become Self-Defeating
Using a motte-and-bailey definition of an offense (a bland defensible definition and a much broader contestable one used interchangeably) combined with a punishment as severe as social death causes people to demand a very high burden of proof and apply the punishment only to the narrowest cases, which paradoxically excludes genuinely problematic things like structural sexism and erodes support for fighting racism and bigotry.
causalpending
Speaker
Megan McArdleEvidence Quote
“When you over-broaden it, you actually lose support for fighting racism, for fighting sexism, for fighting all sorts of bigotry. Because, you've made it so broad and you've made the penalty so high that people just throw up their hands”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:24:26 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...