causal

Religion and ethnic identity explain English brutality to Irish

The English were more brutal to the Irish than to the Scots primarily because the Irish were overwhelmingly Catholic, which in the 17th-century geopolitical context made them seen as an entry point for hostile continental Catholic powers (Spain, France) and therefore ipso facto disloyal, whereas lowland Scotland adapted to Protestant union and profited from the empire.

causalpending

Speaker

Roy Foster

Evidence Quote

“it comes down to religion and ethnicus, if I can put it that way: a kind of cultural, ethnic identity.”

Source

Roy Foster— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:25:52 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...