causal

Metabolism-first conflicts with the second law

The metabolism-first origin theory faces a fundamental problem, as Sonia Lipson noted: it asks disorganized matter to become organized, which the second law disfavors—you cannot start life with a counter-thermodynamic process; the DKS idea overcomes this because incoming energy changes the rules.

causalpending

Speaker

Addy Pross

Evidence Quote

“What this new dynamic, kinetic state idea does is to overcome the metabolism problem... because if you get energy coming in, the rules change.”

Source

294 | Addy Pross on Dynamics, Stability, and Life— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:29:34 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...