What this covers

Addy Pross, a chemist at Ben-Gurion University, argues that the standard biological account of life is incomplete and rests on unstable ground. In this conversation with Sean Carroll, he proposes that life is best understood through a chemical lens: as a replicating system in Dynamic Kinetic Stability (DKS), a recently discovered dynamic kinetic state of matter that lies beyond the familiar thermodynamic categories. The core insight is that persistence in time—the property Schrödinger emphasized—is more fundamental than stability in energy. A DKS system, like a water fountain, can be energetically unstable yet temporally stable, persisting through continuous turnover as energy and matter flow through it. Once such a system becomes replicative, it enters an evolutionary regime governed by what Pross calls the Persistence Principle: systems naturally evolve from less persistent to more persistent forms, a direction evolution acquires not by design but by competition for resources.

The discussion ranges across implications for origin-of-life research, where Pross identifies a critical failure in RNA-world experiments—they evolve toward simplicity, not complexity—and across fundamental biology, where he challenges the central dogma and genome-centric neo-Darwinism by invoking Denis Noble's argument that the cell controls the genome, not vice versa. He argues for Holistic Self-Replication, where no individual molecule replicates in isolation but the cell as a closed loop does. Most provocatively, Pross extends DKS logic to cognition: because a DKS system depends existentially on its environment for survival, it develops rudimentary awareness of both environment and self. This plants consciousness not as a late evolutionary arrival but as a graded Spectrum of Cognition beginning with bacteria and scaling upward. The thread connecting these positions is a single conceptual reframing—that life is a kinetic phenomenon, not merely a thermodynamic puzzle—and Pross treats it as a Paradigm Shift overdue in biology.

Sharpest takeaway

Pross argues that life is best understood as a replicating chemical system in a 'dynamic kinetic stability' (DKS) state—a kinetic, not thermodynamic, state of matter that persists in time by continuously turning over while consuming free energy—and that this reframes the origin of life, evolution's directionality, and even the emergence of cognition.

  • Stability in time (persistence) is more fundamental than stability in energy, and DKS systems are energetically unstable but persistent like a fountain
  • Once a DKS system becomes replicative it can evolve, and a quantitative predator-prey-style law drives systems from less persistent to more persistent forms, yielding complexification
  • Because a DKS system is existentially dependent on its environment, it has rudimentary awareness of self and environment—the seed of cognition and consciousness

The argument · threads8 threads · 33 claims
0.85

Dynamic kinetic stability requires continuous free energy flow; systems collapse without it, like a fountain when its pump stops.

6 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Counter-thermodynamic organization—houses, life, all built order—can only occur as long as energy is available; most of life's energy on Earth is solar, and once the solar energy stops, all life will collapse like a fountain whose pump is turned off, ending in heat death.

    “that will only happen for a limited period of time, as long as energy is available. Once the energy stops, everything stops.”

  • Dynamic kinetic stability requires not just energy but free energy—energy in a useful form—coming in continuously; once the energy stops, the persistent structure collapses just as a fountain dies when the pump stops.

    “as long as you have energy provided to them”

  • The metabolism-first origin theory faces a fundamental problem, as Sonia Lipson noted: it asks disorganized matter to become organized, which the second law disfavors—you cannot start life with a counter-thermodynamic process; the DKS idea overcomes this because incoming energy changes the rules.

    “you are asking, disorganized matter to become organized. Now, the second law doesn't like that... So you can't start off life with a counter thermodynamic process.”

  • For one thermodynamic process or state there are thousands to millions of potential kinetic states, depending for example on the proportion of acid and ester in a hydrogel, giving tunable properties (more solid vs softer)—a flexibility life exploits in every motion as cells shift between dynamic kinetic states.

    “for that one thermodynamic process with one thermodynamic state, you have thousands, literally millions of kinetic, potential kinetic states, depending on the proportion of the acid and the ester”

  • The body is a DKS system at multiple levels—molecular, cellular, organismal, and societal—because every cell continually turns over its molecules and the body sheds and renews cells (some faster than others), so in a few months the matter constituting you is largely replaced.

    “every cell in your body is a DKS system because the cell is a dynamic kinetic system where all the molecules in the cell are continually turning over”

  • The cytoskeleton is a DKS system: cells shift between rigid structure (more microtubules) and softer structure (degraded to tubulin dimers) to suit requirements like transport or motion, with tubulin and microtubules acting as the analogs of acid and ester, all while continually dissipating energy as heat.

    “the cytoskeleton needs to have dynamic function in order to suit the cell's requirements... it's a DKS system made up... of tubulin dimers and microtubules”

0.80

Life is a replicating chemical system in dynamic kinetic state, a new dimension of matter enabling counter-thermodynamic organization.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Life can be defined as a replicating chemical system existing in the dynamic kinetic state—a newly discovered kinetic state of matter beyond the familiar thermodynamic states—which in principle gives a recipe for how to make life.

    “And life, if I have to define life now, I would say it's a replicating chemical system in this dynamic kinetic state, this new state of matter that's been recently discovered.”

  • The new kinetic state of matter is analogous to discovering flight: just as no amount of land travel gets you airborne because flight is a new dimension, attempts to make life by manipulating proteins and nucleic acids in a test tube fail because life requires accessing this new kinetic dimension of matter.

    “It's the same with this new kinetic state of matter. It's the equivalent of flight, in that we've discovered we've accessed a new means of doing things.”

  • When two Dutch chemists ran the classic esterification reaction dynamically—continually forming ester from acid and degrading it back—they got not crystals but a hydrogel, a new form of matter composed of both ester and acid in a dynamic process.

    “if you do this reaction in a dynamic way, namely turn the acid into the ester, and then continually degrade the ester back to acid, and then make more ester all the time in this dynamic way, you end up with a new form of matter. You end up with a hydrogel.”

  • Beyond the familiar thermodynamic states of matter, chemistry has discovered in the last 10-15 years that there are kinetic states of matter—a remarkable finding given how established chemistry is.

    “beyond the familiar thermodynamic states of matter, there are kinetic states of matter”

  • A water fountain is the paradigmatic metaphor for kinetic stability: the fountain as an entity is persistent and stable in time, yet energetically unstable since the water is suspended in midair—it persists only because it is continually created in a dynamic way with energy and matter flowing through it.

    “the fountain as an entity is persistent, stable in this time sense, but the water drops in the fountain are continually turning over”

0.61

Evolution has a directional gradient toward increasing persistence and complexity, never reversing, as systems compete for resources.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Contrary to the common biological view that evolution is without direction, evolutionary history has a direction: systems go from less persistent to more persistent forms (Steve Grant's principle), never evolving in reverse, moving toward increasing complexity for increasing persistence.

    “biologists tend to think of evolution as without direction. That is not true. Evolution... This history has a direction and the direction is very simple as that, simple, differential equation that I described earlier states, systems go from less persistent to more persistent.”

  • Once two DKS systems compete for the same resource, the predator-prey-style differential equation that describes DKS formation and decay says explicitly that the more persistent system will drive the less persistent one into extinction—'sucking the water out of the other fountain'—so a mutation conferring greater (environment-dependent) persistence will thrive, which is the beginning of memory.

    “once you have two DKS systems competing for the same resource, the math says quite explicitly that the more stable, the more persistent one will drive the less persistent one into extinction”

  • The power of replication is awesome (a single fertilized egg becomes ~50-70 trillion cells via ~40-45 replications), but per Malthus you can't sustain it; the best outcome is a balance between formation rate and decay rate tuned to lifespan—flies live a day, humans nearly a hundred years—and nature returns to that balance, kindly or cruelly, if replication ignores the Malthusian rule.

    “the best you can hope for, and this is where we are all the time, a balance, you have rate of formation balanced by a rate of decay and these have to be, attuned to one another.”

  • Evolution proceeds along both physical and mental dimensions, as Darwin foresaw; the mental dimension cannot pop up willy-nilly midway because evolution improves on something already present, so cognition and consciousness have been part of the evolutionary process from the beginning—directed, like the second law, even though kinetic space is divergent rather than convergent.

    “Darwin already foresaw the mental dimension as being there from the beginning of the evolutionary process”

0.61

The cell holistically self-replicates as a closed cycle; the genome is one important part, not the sole replicator controlling cellular behavior.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Contrary to viewing DNA as a read-only system, Jim Shapiro argues it is a read-write system; combined with Barbara McClintock's discovery of jumping genes (ridiculed until vindicated decades later), this supports the view that the cell actively controls and rewrites the genome.

    “DNA is thought of as a read only system. He says it's a read write system.”

  • When a bacterium survives a viral attack it deliberately incorporates a piece of the viral DNA into its own genome (the CRISPR system), so that next time it recognizes and cuts the viral DNA—a deliberate, non-accidental genome change that is the opposite of the dogma that DNA mutation is purely random.

    “it takes a little bit of that viral DNA and puts it into its own genome. In other words, it changes its genome, that's not an accidental mutation, that's a deliberate change in its genome”

  • No element of the cell self-replicates on its own (a DNA molecule with nucleotides thrown at it makes no copies); rather, the cell is holistically self-replicating—a closed cycle where A makes B, B makes C... and the loop closes—so the genome is one important part of the holistic cycle, not the sole replicator, requiring modification of the central dogma.

    “The cell is holistically self replicating. In other words, no element in it on its own is self replicating.”

  • The genome-centric neo-Darwinian paradigm is overrated and in crisis, patched by 'band aids' like horizontal gene transfer and epigenetics; as Denis Noble argues, the cell controls the genome rather than the genome controlling the cell, since all cell types share the same genome and the cell uses only the relevant bits—so the genome is an important memory store but just one part of a holistically self-replicating cycle.

    “the general view is that the genome controls the cell. He says it's actually the other way around. The cell controls the genome.”

0.61

The neo-Darwinian genome-centric paradigm is failing and requires replacement by a framework encompassing dynamic kinetic stability and holistic replication.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • A failing paradigm is not replaced by its own failures; when it stops working, practitioners add band-aids, and only a new paradigm encompassing the new information can replace it—which has been slow to emerge in biology.

    “you cannot replace an old paradigm with a new one, the paradigm doesn't change through failures in the old paradigm because what happens when the paradigm starts to not work, you add band aids.”

  • There are literally hundreds of definitions of life, and the very fact that there are so many means probably none of them are very good—otherwise we wouldn't need hundreds.

    “There are literally hundreds of definitions of life, and the fact that there are so many definitions means that probably none of them are very good, otherwise we wouldn't need hundreds of definitions.”

  • In the RNA-world experiments, replicating molecules do evolve via copying mistakes, but they evolve toward simplicity rather than life: a molecule of ~5,000 segments shrinks to ~500 because shorter molecules replicate faster and out-replicate longer ones—going from complexity to simplicity, the opposite of what is needed, which has stymied origin-of-life thinking for 50-60 years.

    “the replicating molecule became shorter and shorter and shorter. It started out with something like 5,000 segments and ended up with something like 500 segments. And the reason was very simple. The 500 segment molecule replicated faster than the longer molecule.”

  • To create life you need a DKS system that is also replicative so it can undergo change and become more persistent, but combining DKS stability with replication has not yet been achieved experimentally—whoever figures it out deserves a Nobel Prize.

    “to make a system that is both DKS stable and replicative, we're not there yet.”

0.56

Cognition and consciousness form a graded spectrum present from life's origin, with organisms sensing and responding to environment for persistence.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Consciousness and cognition started at the very beginning of evolution and form a graded spectrum: if humans are at 9.5, bacteria are at 0.3—bacteria are cognitive (though Pross avoids calling them conscious) because they sense and respond to their environment to solve problems, and humans are simply much better at it.

    “on the spectrum from 0 to 10, if we're, at 9.5, the bacteria are at 0.3. But they have something there in order for them to deal with the problems that they encounter”

  • Because a DKS system is existentially dependent on its environment for resources and energy, it is aware in a rudimentary sense of its environment—and distinguishing itself from the environment is the beginning of self-awareness; an evolutionary process enhancing this for persistence yields increasingly self-aware and externally aware systems, from bacteria up to humans looking into space.

    “the fact that DKS system is totally dependent, existentially dependent on its environment for resources and energy, that means it is aware in a very rudimentary sense of its environment, because without that it dies.”

  • Under the definition that cognition is a system able to store, access, and act on information, a DKS system is cognitive by definition: the incoming energy and material are information input it acquires and responds to—so the beginning of cognition is visible in DKS behavior, with self-awareness arising because dealing with the outside requires monitoring one's internal state.

    “There's a definition of cognition that is a system that is able to store, access, and act on information. But that's exactly what a DKS system does.”

0.43

Organisms carry mutual information with and memory of their environment encoded through millions of years of continuous adaptation.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Every biological organism has a huge amount of mutual information with its environment—not because it consciously thinks about it but because it is adapted to survive there—so every cell contains within it a history of millions of years of continual adaptation.

    “every cell contains within its history going back, millions of years. Because that's been a continual adaptation, to its environment.”

  • The persistence of simple bacteria does not contradict complexification because bacteria are not simple in isolation—they live in interconnected networks where living things interact (e.g., the microbiome), so life is a complex, continually complexifying network, echoing Lovelock's Gaia idea that everything is connected.

    “bacteria aren't simple at all, they live in networks. They don't live individually and all life is increasingly an interconnected network where all the living things are interacting with one another.”

  • Life has been around for close to 4 billion years, bacteria for most of that time, making it extremely persistent—stable in the time sense.

    “life has been around for close to 4 billion years, bacteria for most of that time. That is pretty persistent, pretty stable in the time sense.”

0.34

Life's persistence and apparent improbability suggest emergence of replicating dynamic kinetic systems is highly contingent, occurring elsewhere unknown.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Whether life arises elsewhere is unknown because the emergence of a DKS system and its becoming replicative appears highly contingent; Pross cannot estimate the probability, noting only that it happened once.

    “the high contingency means the probability that it will happen... I am at a loss, I do not know the likelihood of that, except that it did happen once.”

  • Human technology is always far behind natural technology—nature discovered things like neural networks long before humans, so nature is smarter than we are, though it took a long time.

    “human technology is always way behind natural technology. Nature is so very smart”

  • Because nature equips us with cognitive tools to persist and consciousness consumes about 20% of our energy, nature would not invest that unless there were a return; therefore what we perceive must largely be really there, since organisms that lose track of reality cannot survive—so the world is not an illusion.

    “Consciousness, our mental activity apparently takes up something like 20% of our energy... Nature wouldn't do that if there wasn't some return for that.”

  • Stability has two distinct meanings—low energy (thermodynamic) and persistence over time (everyday sense)—which usually overlap but need not; time stability is more fundamental because it encompasses both kinetically stable systems and energetically stable systems, so something can be energetically unstable yet stable in time.

    “you can have stuff that is unstable in energy terms, but stable in time terms and time stability is in a sense more fundamental than energy stability because it encompasses both kinetically stable systems and energetically stable systems”