Socrates defeats Thrasymachus by getting him to redefine justice not as a principle in the state but as justice in the soul—internal integrity—showing that justice is self-control and that without control of passions, vices, and emotions one cannot be just even to oneself, and therefore a tyrant lacking self-control cannot have the best life.

causalpending

Speaker

Jeff Brenzel

Evidence Quote

“he gets Thrasymachus to redefine justice, look away from justice in the State, but look at justice in the soul...if you're not in control of your own passions and emotions and vices and so forth that you can't be just even to yourself...the tyrant doesn't have the best life”

Source

Jeffrey Brenzel: The Essential Value of a Classic Education | Big Think— Big Think
Created: 8/10/2026, 11:08:00 PM

Your notes

Loading notes...