causal

Firing bottom 5% of teachers by test scores fails

The theory that schools should fire the bottom 5% of teachers each year based on test-score gains never worked and is self-defeating, because it simply identifies teachers working with the lowest-performing students, who show the smallest gains; wherever value-added by test scores has been tried, the best teachers turn out to be those in the best schools with the wealthiest kids.

causalpending

Speaker

Diane Ravitch

Evidence Quote

“you're basically identifying the teachers who are working with the lowest-performing kids because they don't see the big gains... the best teachers are in the best schools.”

Source

Diane Ravitch on Slaying Goliath— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:17:36 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...