causal

Reasoning from a Price Change Fallacy

Interpreting the effect of a price change without identifying its cause is a fallacy ('reasoning from a price change'): a high oil price implies lower consumption only if supply fell (e.g. OPEC cut), but implies higher consumption if demand shifted out (a booming economy), so the same observed price move can mean opposite things depending on which curve moved.

causalpending

Speaker

Scott Sumner

Evidence Quote

“He's doing what I call 'reasoning from a price change.'”

Source

Scott Sumner on Interest Rates— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:14:03 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...