Odysseus kills all 108 suitors who occupied his house and courtship Penelope during his absence, but the suitors make a reasonable case that they thought him dead after 20 years, never touched Penelope, and offer to replace anything they consumed, raising the question of whether such total destruction constitutes justice or represents an act of excessive ruthlessness.

factualpending

Speaker

Stanley Lombardo

Evidence Quote

“The suitors make a good case. They say, "Look, we're going to replace anything that we touched here... We never touched Penelope. We really thought you were dead. It has been 20 years. Why did he kill all of them?”

Source

Roundtable Discussion on Homer's "The Odyssey" featuring Christopher Hitchens— C-SPAN's Book TV
Created: 8/12/2026, 5:57:46 PM

Your notes

Loading notes...