There is nothing in the writings of the Bolsheviks explaining how a single central state planning authority could ever gather information quickly enough and process it well enough to run an entire economy permanently; they acted 'on a wing and a prayer,' assuming they could work it out as they went — which vindicates Hayek's twin arguments that socialist central planning was impractical and would lead to despotism.

causalpending

Speaker

Robert Service

Evidence Quote

“they seem to have acted on earth sort of a wing in a prayer they seem to think that they could work it out as they went along”

Source

Robert Service on Trotsky 07/26/2010— EconTalk
Created: 6/16/2026, 2:24:37 PM

Your notes

Loading notes...