normative

Too Coercive Is A Conclusion In Search Of An Argument

The claim that banning smoking is 'too coercive' is a conclusion in search of an argument; the real shorthand is that the all-things-considered welfare consequences of a ban would be negative, but that has to be earned rather than asserted, and the goal is that whatever one's metaphysical assumptions, one can reach conclusions compatible with nonsectarian welfarism — with liberty counting both as an ingredient in welfare and as a Millian heuristic since people generally know better than third parties what makes their lives go better.

normativepending

Speaker

Cass Sunstein

Evidence Quote

“to see liberty as an ingredient in welfare because of its exercise and to see it as a heuristic for what’s actually going to promote welfare — those are both good ideas”

Source

Cass Sunstein— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/12/2026, 4:58:56 PM

Your notes

Loading notes...